{"cultivar":{"id":238,"name":"Ben Davis","normalized_name":"ben davis","taxon_id":1,"source_document_id":44,"created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:19"},"facet":{"id":197,"cultivar_id":238,"usage_class":"edible","edible_score":1.0,"ornamental_score":0.0,"inferred_from_taxon":true,"source_document_id":44,"created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:19","updated_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:19"},"zone_assertions":[],"relationships":[{"id":206,"relation_type":"offered_by_candidate_nursery","subject_entity_type":"cultivar","subject_entity_id":238,"object_entity_type":"nursery","object_entity_id":17,"source_document_id":44,"created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:19"},{"id":202,"relation_type":"cross_parent","subject_entity_type":"cultivar","subject_entity_id":128,"object_entity_type":"cultivar","object_entity_id":238,"source_document_id":44,"created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:19"}],"evidence_claims":[{"id":18109,"subject_entity_type":"cultivar","subject_entity_id":238,"claim_type":"description_snippet","claim_text":"Ben Davis also has obovate cells.","normalized_claim_text":"ben davis also has obovate cells","confidence":0.94,"source_document_id":14,"source_fragment_id":3467,"source_extracted_claim_id":null,"created_at":"2026-04-16T16:10:46"},{"id":18108,"subject_entity_type":"cultivar","subject_entity_id":238,"claim_type":"fruit_size","claim_text":"Ben Davis is noted as having large fruit.","normalized_claim_text":"ben davis is noted as having large fruit","confidence":0.96,"source_document_id":14,"source_fragment_id":3467,"source_extracted_claim_id":null,"created_at":"2026-04-16T16:10:46"},{"id":15757,"subject_entity_type":"cultivar","subject_entity_id":238,"claim_type":"description_snippet","claim_text":"Deep abrupt basin is repeatedly noted in this cultivar and a long growing season is described as necessary.","normalized_claim_text":"deep abrupt basin is repeatedly noted in this cultivar and a long growing season is described as necessary","confidence":0.9,"source_document_id":14,"source_fragment_id":5693,"source_extracted_claim_id":null,"created_at":"2026-04-16T16:10:36"},{"id":15756,"subject_entity_type":"cultivar","subject_entity_id":238,"claim_type":"fruit_size","claim_text":"Fruit is characterized as large and roundish conical.","normalized_claim_text":"fruit is characterized as large and roundish conical","confidence":0.84,"source_document_id":14,"source_fragment_id":5693,"source_extracted_claim_id":null,"created_at":"2026-04-16T16:10:36"},{"id":15755,"subject_entity_type":"cultivar","subject_entity_id":238,"claim_type":"selection_origin_reference","claim_text":"Cultivar is successfully raised in South Dakota near the Missouri River by E. L. Collar and others in Vermillion.","normalized_claim_text":"cultivar is successfully raised in south dakota near the missouri river by e l collar and others in vermillion","confidence":0.86,"source_document_id":14,"source_fragment_id":5693,"source_extracted_claim_id":null,"created_at":"2026-04-16T16:10:36"},{"id":15754,"subject_entity_type":"cultivar","subject_entity_id":238,"claim_type":"anecdote_snippet","claim_text":"E. D. Cowles stated growers learned to grow Ben Davis as a bush rather than as a tree.","normalized_claim_text":"e d cowles stated growers learned to grow ben davis as a bush rather than as a tree","confidence":0.96,"source_document_id":14,"source_fragment_id":5693,"source_extracted_claim_id":null,"created_at":"2026-04-16T16:10:36"},{"id":15753,"subject_entity_type":"cultivar","subject_entity_id":238,"claim_type":"growth_habit","claim_text":"Described as doing best as low-headed trees and often as sprouts from trees previously killed to the ground.","normalized_claim_text":"described as doing best as low headed trees and often as sprouts from trees previously killed to the ground","confidence":0.93,"source_document_id":14,"source_fragment_id":5693,"source_extracted_claim_id":null,"created_at":"2026-04-16T16:10:36"},{"id":15752,"subject_entity_type":"cultivar","subject_entity_id":238,"claim_type":"entry_hardiness_observation","claim_text":"Observed as not sufficiently hardy in northern Iowa and reported winter-killed in 1884-85 farther south.","normalized_claim_text":"observed as not sufficiently hardy in northern iowa and reported winter killed in 1884 85 farther south","confidence":0.94,"source_document_id":14,"source_fragment_id":5693,"source_extracted_claim_id":null,"created_at":"2026-04-16T16:10:36"},{"id":15751,"subject_entity_type":"cultivar","subject_entity_id":238,"claim_type":"recommendation_context","claim_text":"Historically described as the leading winter market apple in Missouri and other southern sections.","normalized_claim_text":"historically described as the leading winter market apple in missouri and other southern sections","confidence":0.95,"source_document_id":14,"source_fragment_id":5693,"source_extracted_claim_id":null,"created_at":"2026-04-16T16:10:36"},{"id":15750,"subject_entity_type":"cultivar","subject_entity_id":238,"claim_type":"selection_origin_reference","claim_text":"Origin is uncertain, likely Virginia or Tennessee.","normalized_claim_text":"origin is uncertain likely virginia or tennessee","confidence":0.98,"source_document_id":14,"source_fragment_id":5693,"source_extracted_claim_id":null,"created_at":"2026-04-16T16:10:36"},{"id":15474,"subject_entity_type":"cultivar","subject_entity_id":238,"claim_type":"recommendation_context","claim_text":"Named in the District 7 winter-apple recommendation set.","normalized_claim_text":"named in the district 7 winter apple recommendation set","confidence":0.99,"source_document_id":14,"source_fragment_id":5680,"source_extracted_claim_id":null,"created_at":"2026-04-16T16:10:35"},{"id":15426,"subject_entity_type":"cultivar","subject_entity_id":238,"claim_type":"anecdote_snippet","claim_text":"Many Ben Davis seedlings are described as too similar to the parent to justify introduction.","normalized_claim_text":"many ben davis seedlings are described as too similar to the parent to justify introduction","confidence":0.91,"source_document_id":14,"source_fragment_id":5677,"source_extracted_claim_id":null,"created_at":"2026-04-16T16:10:35"},{"id":15425,"subject_entity_type":"cultivar","subject_entity_id":238,"claim_type":"entry_location","claim_text":"The southwest is described as having many Ben Davis seedlings.","normalized_claim_text":"the southwest is described as having many ben davis seedlings","confidence":0.95,"source_document_id":14,"source_fragment_id":5677,"source_extracted_claim_id":null,"created_at":"2026-04-16T16:10:35"},{"id":7516,"subject_entity_type":"cultivar","subject_entity_id":238,"claim_type":"description_snippet","claim_text":"Listed as a standard apple (standard apple, fruit 5 cm diameter or more).","normalized_claim_text":"listed as a standard apple standard apple fruit 5 cm diameter or more","confidence":0.96,"source_document_id":3,"source_fragment_id":5585,"source_extracted_claim_id":null,"created_at":"2026-03-13T14:12:34"},{"id":7515,"subject_entity_type":"cultivar","subject_entity_id":238,"claim_type":"taxon_context","claim_text":"Code ST indicates a standard apple with fruit 5 cm diameter or more.","normalized_claim_text":"code st indicates a standard apple with fruit 5 cm diameter or more","confidence":0.95,"source_document_id":3,"source_fragment_id":5585,"source_extracted_claim_id":null,"created_at":"2026-03-13T14:12:34"},{"id":7514,"subject_entity_type":"cultivar","subject_entity_id":238,"claim_type":"description_snippet","claim_text":"Synonym noted: Baltimore Pippen.","normalized_claim_text":"synonym noted baltimore pippen","confidence":0.95,"source_document_id":3,"source_fragment_id":5585,"source_extracted_claim_id":null,"created_at":"2026-03-13T14:12:34"},{"id":7513,"subject_entity_type":"cultivar","subject_entity_id":238,"claim_type":"source_reference_abbreviation","claim_text":"References cited: Starkes cat. and CGS (Morden).","normalized_claim_text":"references cited starkes cat and cgs morden","confidence":0.93,"source_document_id":3,"source_fragment_id":5585,"source_extracted_claim_id":null,"created_at":"2026-03-13T14:12:34"},{"id":7512,"subject_entity_type":"cultivar","subject_entity_id":238,"claim_type":"description_snippet","claim_text":"A note says it was replaced by Black Ben.","normalized_claim_text":"a note says it was replaced by black ben","confidence":0.85,"source_document_id":3,"source_fragment_id":5585,"source_extracted_claim_id":null,"created_at":"2026-03-13T14:12:34"},{"id":3564,"subject_entity_type":"cultivar","subject_entity_id":238,"claim_type":"breeding_cross","claim_text":"Malinda x Ben Davis","normalized_claim_text":"malinda x ben davis","confidence":0.65,"source_document_id":44,"source_fragment_id":2272,"source_extracted_claim_id":2580,"created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:19"}],"history_events":[{"id":445,"event_type":"selection_origin_event","label":"Selection origin 1913, tested as Minn","normalized_label":"selection origin 1913, tested as minn","event_year":1913,"source_document_id":44,"note":"auto-extracted selection-origin marker","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:19"},{"id":444,"event_type":"selection_origin_event","label":"Selection origin Morristown by Seth Kelly, and developed by the University of Minnesota","normalized_label":"selection origin morristown by seth kelly, and developed by the university of minnesota","event_year":null,"source_document_id":44,"note":"auto-extracted selection-origin marker","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:19"},{"id":443,"event_type":"release_event","label":"Release event 1923","normalized_label":"release event 1923","event_year":1923,"source_document_id":44,"note":"auto-extracted release-year marker","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:19"},{"id":442,"event_type":"cross_event","label":"Malinda x Ben Davis","normalized_label":"malinda x ben davis","event_year":1923,"source_document_id":44,"note":"auto-extracted breeding cross","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:19"}],"linked_entities":[{"relation_type":"offered_by_candidate_nursery","entity_type":"nursery","entity_id":17,"label":"Prairie Orchards"},{"relation_type":"cross_parent","entity_type":"cultivar","entity_id":128,"label":"Malinda"}]}