{"document":{"id":34,"title":"Columbia","url":"https://research-groups.usask.ca/fruit/documents/apples/Columbia.pdf","source_type":"pdf","language":"en","accessed_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15.243424","rights_status":"unknown","source_target_id":null,"provenance_note":"source_site=University of Saskatchewan Fruit Program | institution=University of Saskatchewan | source_root=https://research-groups.usask.ca/fruit/documents/apples/ | local_archive=/usr/local/var/www/pomologica/data/raw/manual/ingest_queue/research_groups_20260309/Columbia.pdf"},"citation":{"document_id":34,"title":"Columbia","url":"https://research-groups.usask.ca/fruit/documents/apples/Columbia.pdf","source_type":"pdf","language":"en","published_at":null,"accessed_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15.243424","rights_status":"unknown","source_target_id":null,"provenance_events":[{"id":136,"document_id":34,"ingestion_job_id":null,"event_type":"source_provenance_backfilled","source_url":"https://research-groups.usask.ca/fruit/documents/apples/Columbia.pdf","note":"Backfilled original source metadata; site=University of Saskatchewan Fruit Program; institution=University of Saskatchewan; local_archive=/usr/local/var/www/pomologica/data/raw/manual/ingest_queue/research_groups_20260309/Columbia.pdf","created_at":"2026-03-09T18:33:54"},{"id":37,"document_id":34,"ingestion_job_id":42,"event_type":"ingest_file_created","source_url":"file:///usr/local/var/www/pomologica/data/raw/manual/ingest_queue/research_groups_20260309/Columbia.pdf","note":"queued pdf batch import 2026-03-09","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"}],"rights_records":[{"id":35,"document_id":34,"rights_status":"unknown","license_name":null,"rights_holder":null,"rights_url":null,"permission_contact":null,"note":"auto-created from ingestion request","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"}],"translation_records":[],"translation_assessments":[],"publication_records":[],"credibility_records":[{"id":35,"document_id":34,"credibility_tier":"tier_3","score_100":55,"rationale":"Unclassified domain; requires manual source evaluation","assessor":"auto","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"}],"fragment_anchors":["fragment:page:1","fragment:paragraph:0","fragment:paragraph:1","fragment:paragraph:2","fragment:paragraph:3","fragment:paragraph:4","fragment:paragraph:5","fragment:paragraph:6","fragment:paragraph:7","fragment:paragraph:8","fragment:paragraph:9","fragment:paragraph:10","fragment:paragraph:11","fragment:preview:0","fragment:page:1:visual_v1","fragment:document:visual_context_v1","fragment:document:citation_queue_v1"]},"aliases":[{"id":36,"document_id":34,"url":"file:///usr/local/var/www/pomologica/data/raw/manual/ingest_queue/research_groups_20260309/Columbia.pdf","observed_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"}],"extracted_entities":[{"id":466,"document_id":34,"fragment_id":2129,"entity_type":"nursery_candidate","value":"Central Experimental Farm","normalized_value":"central experimental farm","confidence":0.58,"extractor_version":"v0.2","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":465,"document_id":34,"fragment_id":2129,"entity_type":"nursery_candidate","value":"Prairie Orchards","normalized_value":"prairie orchards","confidence":0.58,"extractor_version":"v0.2","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":464,"document_id":34,"fragment_id":2129,"entity_type":"nursery_candidate","value":"Dominion Experimental Farm","normalized_value":"dominion experimental farm","confidence":0.58,"extractor_version":"v0.2","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":463,"document_id":34,"fragment_id":2129,"entity_type":"taxon_keyword","value":"malus","normalized_value":"malus","confidence":0.65,"extractor_version":"v0.2","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"}],"extracted_claims":[{"id":2402,"document_id":34,"fragment_id":2129,"claim_type":"description_snippet","claim_text":"Note: Columbia seedlings are vigorous , even, very hardy and therefore excellent for rootstock, which is its only use today.","confidence":0.54,"extractor_version":"v0.2","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":2401,"document_id":34,"fragment_id":2129,"claim_type":"description_snippet","claim_text":"The tree is very vigorous, tall, and rounded, very productive.","confidence":0.54,"extractor_version":"v0.2","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":2400,"document_id":34,"fragment_id":2129,"claim_type":"description_snippet","claim_text":"Columbia seedlings are vigorous, even, and valuable as rootstocks.","confidence":0.54,"extractor_version":"v0.2","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":2399,"document_id":34,"fragment_id":2129,"claim_type":"description_snippet","claim_text":"Fruit to 1 4/5 inches, conic, ribbed pale green well washed red, some stripes of dark red; flesh yellowish, juicy, sub-acid, slightly astringent; quality fair; season late September and October.","confidence":0.54,"extractor_version":"v0.2","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":2398,"document_id":34,"fragment_id":2129,"claim_type":"ornamental_use","claim_text":"Ornamental","confidence":0.56,"extractor_version":"v0.2","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":2397,"document_id":34,"fragment_id":2129,"claim_type":"culinary_use","claim_text":"canning, and stores for 5 weeks","confidence":0.56,"extractor_version":"v0.2","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":2396,"document_id":34,"fragment_id":2129,"claim_type":"culinary_use","claim_text":"sauce, but too sour for eating raw\" Recommended by Robert Erskine, Rocky Mountain","confidence":0.56,"extractor_version":"v0.2","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":2395,"document_id":34,"fragment_id":2129,"claim_type":"culinary_use","claim_text":"juice and jelly canned and","confidence":0.56,"extractor_version":"v0.2","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":2394,"document_id":34,"fragment_id":2129,"claim_type":"productivity","claim_text":"productive","confidence":0.56,"extractor_version":"v0.2","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":2393,"document_id":34,"fragment_id":2129,"claim_type":"ripening_window","claim_text":"matures in late September","confidence":0.56,"extractor_version":"v0.2","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":2392,"document_id":34,"fragment_id":2129,"claim_type":"ripening_window","claim_text":"ripening","confidence":0.56,"extractor_version":"v0.2","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":2391,"document_id":34,"fragment_id":2129,"claim_type":"fruit_size","claim_text":"3.5 cm","confidence":0.58,"extractor_version":"v0.2","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":2390,"document_id":34,"fragment_id":2129,"claim_type":"fruit_size","claim_text":"4cm","confidence":0.58,"extractor_version":"v0.2","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":2389,"document_id":34,"fragment_id":2129,"claim_type":"growth_habit","claim_text":"vigorous","confidence":0.52,"extractor_version":"v0.2","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":2388,"document_id":34,"fragment_id":2129,"claim_type":"disease_resistance","claim_text":"fire blight","confidence":0.58,"extractor_version":"v0.2","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":2387,"document_id":34,"fragment_id":2129,"claim_type":"selection_origin_reference","claim_text":"Central Experimental Farm, Ottawa, Agriculture Canada, by Dr","confidence":0.57,"extractor_version":"v0.2","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":2386,"document_id":34,"fragment_id":2129,"claim_type":"nursery_reference","claim_text":"Central Experimental Farm","confidence":0.58,"extractor_version":"v0.2","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":2385,"document_id":34,"fragment_id":2129,"claim_type":"nursery_reference","claim_text":"Prairie Orchards","confidence":0.58,"extractor_version":"v0.2","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":2384,"document_id":34,"fragment_id":2129,"claim_type":"nursery_reference","claim_text":"Dominion Experimental Farm","confidence":0.58,"extractor_version":"v0.2","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":2383,"document_id":34,"fragment_id":2129,"claim_type":"breeding_cross","claim_text":"Originated at the Central E x perimental Farm","confidence":0.65,"extractor_version":"v0.2","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":2382,"document_id":34,"fragment_id":2129,"claim_type":"breeding_cross","claim_text":"Dominion E x perimental Farm Service","confidence":0.65,"extractor_version":"v0.2","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":2381,"document_id":34,"fragment_id":2129,"claim_type":"year_reference","claim_text":"1946","confidence":0.55,"extractor_version":"v0.2","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":2380,"document_id":34,"fragment_id":2129,"claim_type":"year_reference","claim_text":"1911","confidence":0.55,"extractor_version":"v0.2","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":2379,"document_id":34,"fragment_id":2129,"claim_type":"hardiness_zone","claim_text":"Zone 1","confidence":0.8,"extractor_version":"v0.2","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"}],"evidence_claims":[{"id":3382,"subject_entity_type":"document","subject_entity_id":34,"claim_type":"description_snippet","claim_text":"Note: Columbia seedlings are vigorous , even, very hardy and therefore excellent for rootstock, which is its only use today.","normalized_claim_text":"note: columbia seedlings are vigorous , even, very hardy and therefore excellent for rootstock, which is its only use today.","confidence":0.54,"source_document_id":34,"source_fragment_id":2129,"source_extracted_claim_id":2402,"created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":3381,"subject_entity_type":"document","subject_entity_id":34,"claim_type":"description_snippet","claim_text":"The tree is very vigorous, tall, and rounded, very productive.","normalized_claim_text":"the tree is very vigorous, tall, and rounded, very productive.","confidence":0.54,"source_document_id":34,"source_fragment_id":2129,"source_extracted_claim_id":2401,"created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":3380,"subject_entity_type":"document","subject_entity_id":34,"claim_type":"description_snippet","claim_text":"Columbia seedlings are vigorous, even, and valuable as rootstocks.","normalized_claim_text":"columbia seedlings are vigorous, even, and valuable as rootstocks.","confidence":0.54,"source_document_id":34,"source_fragment_id":2129,"source_extracted_claim_id":2400,"created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":3379,"subject_entity_type":"document","subject_entity_id":34,"claim_type":"description_snippet","claim_text":"Fruit to 1 4/5 inches, conic, ribbed pale green well washed red, some stripes of dark red; flesh yellowish, juicy, sub-acid, slightly astringent; quality fair; season late September and October.","normalized_claim_text":"fruit to 1 4/5 inches, conic, ribbed pale green well washed red, some stripes of dark red; flesh yellowish, juicy, sub-acid, slightly astringent; quality fair; season late september and october.","confidence":0.54,"source_document_id":34,"source_fragment_id":2129,"source_extracted_claim_id":2399,"created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":3378,"subject_entity_type":"document","subject_entity_id":34,"claim_type":"ornamental_use","claim_text":"Ornamental","normalized_claim_text":"ornamental","confidence":0.56,"source_document_id":34,"source_fragment_id":2129,"source_extracted_claim_id":2398,"created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":3377,"subject_entity_type":"document","subject_entity_id":34,"claim_type":"culinary_use","claim_text":"canning, and stores for 5 weeks","normalized_claim_text":"canning, and stores for 5 weeks","confidence":0.56,"source_document_id":34,"source_fragment_id":2129,"source_extracted_claim_id":2397,"created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":3376,"subject_entity_type":"document","subject_entity_id":34,"claim_type":"culinary_use","claim_text":"sauce, but too sour for eating raw\" Recommended by Robert Erskine, Rocky Mountain","normalized_claim_text":"sauce, but too sour for eating raw\" recommended by robert erskine, rocky mountain","confidence":0.56,"source_document_id":34,"source_fragment_id":2129,"source_extracted_claim_id":2396,"created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":3375,"subject_entity_type":"document","subject_entity_id":34,"claim_type":"culinary_use","claim_text":"juice and jelly canned and","normalized_claim_text":"juice and jelly canned and","confidence":0.56,"source_document_id":34,"source_fragment_id":2129,"source_extracted_claim_id":2395,"created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":3374,"subject_entity_type":"document","subject_entity_id":34,"claim_type":"productivity","claim_text":"productive","normalized_claim_text":"productive","confidence":0.56,"source_document_id":34,"source_fragment_id":2129,"source_extracted_claim_id":2394,"created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":3373,"subject_entity_type":"document","subject_entity_id":34,"claim_type":"ripening_window","claim_text":"matures in late September","normalized_claim_text":"matures in late september","confidence":0.56,"source_document_id":34,"source_fragment_id":2129,"source_extracted_claim_id":2393,"created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":3372,"subject_entity_type":"document","subject_entity_id":34,"claim_type":"ripening_window","claim_text":"ripening","normalized_claim_text":"ripening","confidence":0.56,"source_document_id":34,"source_fragment_id":2129,"source_extracted_claim_id":2392,"created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":3371,"subject_entity_type":"document","subject_entity_id":34,"claim_type":"fruit_size","claim_text":"3.5 cm","normalized_claim_text":"3.5 cm","confidence":0.58,"source_document_id":34,"source_fragment_id":2129,"source_extracted_claim_id":2391,"created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":3370,"subject_entity_type":"document","subject_entity_id":34,"claim_type":"fruit_size","claim_text":"4cm","normalized_claim_text":"4cm","confidence":0.58,"source_document_id":34,"source_fragment_id":2129,"source_extracted_claim_id":2390,"created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":3369,"subject_entity_type":"document","subject_entity_id":34,"claim_type":"growth_habit","claim_text":"vigorous","normalized_claim_text":"vigorous","confidence":0.52,"source_document_id":34,"source_fragment_id":2129,"source_extracted_claim_id":2389,"created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":3368,"subject_entity_type":"document","subject_entity_id":34,"claim_type":"disease_resistance","claim_text":"fire blight","normalized_claim_text":"fire blight","confidence":0.58,"source_document_id":34,"source_fragment_id":2129,"source_extracted_claim_id":2388,"created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":3367,"subject_entity_type":"document","subject_entity_id":34,"claim_type":"selection_origin_reference","claim_text":"Central Experimental Farm, Ottawa, Agriculture Canada, by Dr","normalized_claim_text":"central experimental farm, ottawa, agriculture canada, by dr","confidence":0.57,"source_document_id":34,"source_fragment_id":2129,"source_extracted_claim_id":2387,"created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":3366,"subject_entity_type":"document","subject_entity_id":34,"claim_type":"nursery_reference","claim_text":"Central Experimental Farm","normalized_claim_text":"central experimental farm","confidence":0.58,"source_document_id":34,"source_fragment_id":2129,"source_extracted_claim_id":2386,"created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":3365,"subject_entity_type":"document","subject_entity_id":34,"claim_type":"nursery_reference","claim_text":"Prairie Orchards","normalized_claim_text":"prairie orchards","confidence":0.58,"source_document_id":34,"source_fragment_id":2129,"source_extracted_claim_id":2385,"created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":3364,"subject_entity_type":"document","subject_entity_id":34,"claim_type":"nursery_reference","claim_text":"Dominion Experimental Farm","normalized_claim_text":"dominion experimental farm","confidence":0.58,"source_document_id":34,"source_fragment_id":2129,"source_extracted_claim_id":2384,"created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":3363,"subject_entity_type":"document","subject_entity_id":34,"claim_type":"breeding_cross","claim_text":"Originated at the Central E x perimental Farm","normalized_claim_text":"originated at the central e x perimental farm","confidence":0.65,"source_document_id":34,"source_fragment_id":2129,"source_extracted_claim_id":2383,"created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":3362,"subject_entity_type":"document","subject_entity_id":34,"claim_type":"breeding_cross","claim_text":"Dominion E x perimental Farm Service","normalized_claim_text":"dominion e x perimental farm service","confidence":0.65,"source_document_id":34,"source_fragment_id":2129,"source_extracted_claim_id":2382,"created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":3361,"subject_entity_type":"document","subject_entity_id":34,"claim_type":"year_reference","claim_text":"1946","normalized_claim_text":"1946","confidence":0.55,"source_document_id":34,"source_fragment_id":2129,"source_extracted_claim_id":2381,"created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":3360,"subject_entity_type":"document","subject_entity_id":34,"claim_type":"year_reference","claim_text":"1911","normalized_claim_text":"1911","confidence":0.55,"source_document_id":34,"source_fragment_id":2129,"source_extracted_claim_id":2380,"created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":3359,"subject_entity_type":"document","subject_entity_id":34,"claim_type":"hardiness_zone","claim_text":"Zone 1","normalized_claim_text":"zone 1","confidence":0.8,"source_document_id":34,"source_fragment_id":2129,"source_extracted_claim_id":2379,"created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"}],"relationships":[{"id":181,"relation_type":"mentioned_in_document","subject_entity_type":"nursery","subject_entity_id":16,"object_entity_type":"document","object_entity_id":34,"source_document_id":34,"created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":180,"relation_type":"mentioned_in_document","subject_entity_type":"nursery","subject_entity_id":17,"object_entity_type":"document","object_entity_id":34,"source_document_id":34,"created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":179,"relation_type":"mentioned_in_document","subject_entity_type":"nursery","subject_entity_id":18,"object_entity_type":"document","object_entity_id":34,"source_document_id":34,"created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"}],"history_events":[{"id":372,"event_type":"nursery_mention","label":"Central Experimental Farm","normalized_label":"central experimental farm","event_year":1911,"source_document_id":34,"note":"auto-extracted nursery mention","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":371,"event_type":"nursery_mention","label":"Prairie Orchards","normalized_label":"prairie orchards","event_year":1911,"source_document_id":34,"note":"auto-extracted nursery mention","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":370,"event_type":"nursery_mention","label":"Dominion Experimental Farm","normalized_label":"dominion experimental farm","event_year":1911,"source_document_id":34,"note":"auto-extracted nursery mention","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":369,"event_type":"selection_origin_event","label":"Selection origin Central Experimental Farm, Ottawa, Agriculture Canada, by Dr","normalized_label":"selection origin central experimental farm, ottawa, agriculture canada, by dr","event_year":null,"source_document_id":34,"note":"auto-extracted selection-origin marker","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":368,"event_type":"cross_event","label":"Originated at the Central E x perimental Farm","normalized_label":"originated at the central e x perimental farm","event_year":1911,"source_document_id":34,"note":"auto-extracted breeding cross","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":367,"event_type":"cross_event","label":"Dominion E x perimental Farm Service","normalized_label":"dominion e x perimental farm service","event_year":1911,"source_document_id":34,"note":"auto-extracted breeding cross","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":366,"event_type":"year_reference","label":"Year reference 1946","normalized_label":"year reference 1946","event_year":1946,"source_document_id":34,"note":"auto-extracted temporal marker","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"},{"id":365,"event_type":"year_reference","label":"Year reference 1911","normalized_label":"year reference 1911","event_year":1911,"source_document_id":34,"note":"auto-extracted temporal marker","created_at":"2026-03-09T15:14:15"}],"linked_entities":[{"relation_type":"mentioned_in_document","entity_type":"nursery","entity_id":16,"label":"Central Experimental Farm"},{"relation_type":"mentioned_in_document","entity_type":"nursery","entity_id":17,"label":"Prairie Orchards"},{"relation_type":"mentioned_in_document","entity_type":"nursery","entity_id":18,"label":"Dominion Experimental Farm"}]}