Archivist Page Review

Review parser variants for one source page, compare outputs, and jump directly to the source evidence.

Document: 1 New Hardy Fruits for the Northwest

Source page: Open page 8 in document reader

Institution: Open PRAIRIE | Publisher: | Year: | Pages: 32

Source URL: https://openprairie.sdstate.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1338&context=agexperimentsta_bulletins

Selected Versions

Left: archivist-1.0 (fragment 87)

Right: archivist-1.0 (fragment 10746)

Next Step

Reprocess/promote controls are the next UI layer. The data foundation is now versioned and diffable.

Page Version Diff

Cultivars Added

none

Claims Added

Hopa | culinary_use | The series is described as useful for red sauce and red jelly.
Hopa | description_snippet | The page states: "The first of this series was the Hopa crab."
Hopa | fruit_color | The surrounding series description states that apples in this group have red flowers, skin, and flesh, and that the fruit is red.
Hopa | recommendation_context | The series is described as useful both as ornamental lawn trees and as fancy fruit in the orchard.
Hopa | selection_origin_reference | Hopa is identified as the first of the red-flowered, red-skinned, red-fleshed apple/crabapple series discussed on this page.
Manchurian Crab | entry_location | The source location is given as the mountain region about 50 miles east of Harbin, Manchuria.
Manchurian Crab | fruit_size | The fruit is described as 3/8 to 1/2 inches across, with about 1,650 fruits to a pound.
Manchurian Crab | productivity | The trees are described as heavy croppers for small trees.
Manchurian Crab | recommendation_context | The surrounding paragraph recommends orchards of small-fruited Pyrus baccata forms to furnish a steady supply of seed for stocks.
Manchurian Crab | rootstock_compatibility | The seedlings are described as good for budding and making strong trees; the sentence continues on the next page that they are now in commerce.
Manchurian Crab | selection_origin_reference | Hansen states that he gathered this form in 1924 in the mountain region about 50 miles east of Harbin, Manchuria.
Manchurian Crab | taxon_context | Manchurian crab is identified as Pyrus baccata var. Mandshurica, Maxim.
Red Tip | description_snippet | The source lists Red Tip with Hopa, Redflesh, Zaza, Zelma, and Zita as already reported.
Red Tip | selection_origin_reference | Red Tip is listed among named red-fleshed apple/crabapple selections already reported before or by this bulletin.
Red Tip | taxon_context | The named selections are presented in a section about Redvein crab hybrids with standard apples.
Redflesh | description_snippet | The source lists Redflesh with Hopa, Red Tip, Zaza, Zelma, and Zita as already reported.
Redflesh | selection_origin_reference | Redflesh is listed among named red-fleshed apple/crabapple selections that had already been reported by the time of this bulletin.
Redflesh | taxon_context | The named selections appear in a section discussing Redvein crab hybrids with standard apples.
Redvein Crab | breeder_reference | The source associates the type with Mr. Niedzwetzky, who found it and sent it to Europe, and with Hansen's later breeding work after meeting him at Vernoe, now Alma Ata.
Redvein Crab | description_snippet | The source states that in America the accepted common name is Redvein Crab.

Figures Added

none

Citations Added

S. D. Bulletin 65, Root-killing of Apple Trees, July, 1899

Cultivars Removed

Hopa Crab

Claims Removed

Hopa Crab | culinary_use | The series is described as useful for red sauce and red jelly.
Hopa Crab | description_snippet | It is identified as the first of the series of apples with red flowers, skin, and flesh.
Hopa Crab | fruit_color | It belongs to a series characterized by red flowers, red skin, and red flesh.
Hopa | description_snippet | It is one of the named selections already reported in this red-fleshed breeding line.
Manchurian Crab | description_snippet | About 1,650 fruits weigh a pound.
Manchurian Crab | entry_location | It is noted as coming into prominence in Minnesota.
Manchurian Crab | fruit_size | The fruit is one-half to three-quarters of an inch across.
Manchurian Crab | productivity | These trees are heavy croppers for small trees.
Manchurian Crab | rootstock_compatibility | The seedlings are good for budding and make strong trees.
Manchurian Crab | selection_origin_reference | It was gathered by the writer in 1924 in the mountain region about 50 miles east of Harbin, Manchuria.
Manchurian Crab | taxon_context | It is identified as Pyrus baccata var. Mandshurica, Maxim.
Red Tip | description_snippet | It is one of the named selections already reported in this red-fleshed breeding line.
Redflesh | description_snippet | It is one of the named selections already reported in this red-fleshed breeding line.
Redvein Crab | breeder_reference | The name commemorates Niedzwetzky after he sent it to Europe.
Redvein Crab | description_snippet | It is presented as the source type behind the author's work on red-flowered and red-fleshed apples.
Redvein Crab | entry_location | The author met Mr. Niedzwetzky at Vernoe, now called Alma Ata, in northeast Turkestan, near the Chinese border.
Redvein Crab | selection_origin_reference | Mr. Niedzwetzky found this type of apple in the Tian Shan Mountains separating Russian Turkestan and western China.
Redvein Crab | taxon_context | This type was named Pyrus Malus Niedzwetzkyana.
Virginia Crab | recommendation_context | It is cited as an example of large hybrid crabs that are poor seeders.
Virginia Crab | taxon_context | Cytological research shows it to be a triploid with 51 chromosomes.

Figures Removed

none

Citations Removed

none

Available Page Versions

ID	Variant	Status	Model	Specialization	Counts	Source	Compare
11	archivist-1.0	active	gpt-5.4	visual_page_generalist	11 cultivars / 25 claims / 0 figures	Open source page
3236	archivist-1.0	candidate	gpt-5.4	visual_page_generalist	10 cultivars / 38 claims / 0 figures	Open source page	Compare to active