Archivist Page Review

Review parser variants for one source page, compare outputs, and jump directly to the source evidence.

Document: 14 A Study of Northwestern Apples

Source page: Open page 108 in document reader

Institution: Open PRAIRIE | Publisher: | Year: | Pages: 144

Source URL: https://openprairie.sdstate.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1075&context=agexperimentsta_bulletins

Selected Versions

Left: archivist-1.6.68-spark (fragment 5753)

Right: archivist-1.0 (fragment 3432)

Next Step

Reprocess/promote controls are the next UI layer. The data foundation is now versioned and diffable.

Page Version Diff

Cultivars Added

Tolman
Tyler Seedlings
University

Claims Added

Titovka Speer | caption_context | The page includes a labeled fruit-section figure for Titovka Speer.
Tolman | flavor_profile | very good for a sweet apple.
Tolman | recommendation_context | The American Pomological Society recommends abbreviating the name to Tolman.
Tolman | storage_duration | All winter.
Transcendent Seedling | breeder_reference | Raised by the late J. S. Harris of LaCrescent, Minnesota.
Transcendent Seedling | description_snippet | Dots obscure, minute, many, light russet; cavity wide, obtuse, deep, regular; stem long; basin wide, rather shallow, slightly wrinkled; calyx half open.
Transcendent Seedling | entry_pedigree | An unnamed winter apple raised from seed of Transcendent crab.
Transcendent Seedling | fruit_color | Surface somewhat roughened by the dots, greenish yellow, thinly covered with mixed and striped dull red.
Transcendent Seedling | fruit_size | Fruit medium, oblate, truncated, slightly angular.
Transcendent Seedling | recommendation_context | This variety and the Mills indicate that large apples may be raised from Transcendent crab seed.
Transcendent Seedling | storage_duration | Winter.
Tubbs Ironclad | description_snippet | Cavity wide, obtuse, regular; stem very short; basin regular, broad, very shallow; calyx open.
Tubbs Ironclad | fruit_color | Surface yellow, mostly covered with dull red blush; dots gray, distinct.
Tubbs Ironclad | fruit_size | Fruit medium, oblate, very regular.
Tubbs Ironclad | selection_origin_reference | Tree from F. K. Phoenix; specimens from E. H. S. Dartt, Owatonna, Minnesota.
Tubbs Ironclad | storage_duration | October.
Tyler Seedlings | breeder_reference | These number twenty-five trees raised from seed in 1880 by J. G. Tyler, Hartford township, Minnehaha County, South Dakota.
Tyler Seedlings | description_snippet | No. 15 is said to be a yellow winter apple of excellent quality.
Tyler Seedlings | recommendation_context | The best of these will be described at the first opportunity.
Tyler Seedlings | selection_origin_reference | Introduced by D. F. Harrington, Sioux Falls, South Dakota.

Figures Added

none

Citations Added

none

Cultivars Removed

Tyler Seedlings (No 15)
University (Duchess No. 103)
Wfoter

Claims Removed

Titovka Speer | entry_hardiness_observation | Context suggests winter suitability ("all winter" language appears in nearby narrative blocking for the page sequence).
Titovka Speer | flavor_profile | General quality was noted as good.
Titovka Speer | fruit_color | Fruit color noted as clear pale yellow with bright red stripes and distinct red splashes; occasional blue bloom, with minute white dots.
Titovka Speer | fruit_size | Fruit described as above medium and nearly regular.
Titovka Speer | selection_origin_reference | Suggested as a provisional name; received from Russia by R. P. Speer in Cedar Falls, Iowa, and also seen as a stray importation.
Transcendent Seedling | fruit_color | Greenish yellow fruit, thinly covered with mixed and striped dull red with gray-to-light dots.
Transcendent Seedling | fruit_size | Fruit medium and oblate.
Transcendent Seedling | selection_origin_reference | Raised by J. S. Harris at La Crescent, Minnesota.
Transcendent Seedling | selection_origin_reference | Unspecified official name in this page segment, but described as an unnamed winter apple raised from seed of Transcendent crab.
Tubbs Ironclad | entry_location | Associated with F. K. Phain? (OCR unclear) and specimens from E. H. S. Dartt, Owatonna, Minnesota.
Tubbs Ironclad | fruit_color | Fruit yellow with mostly dull red blush and gray distinct dots.
Tubbs Ironclad | fruit_size | Fruit described as medium and oblate with very regular form.
Tyler Seedlings (No 15) | anecdote_snippet | No. 15 was reported to be a yellow winter apple of excellent quality.
Tyler Seedlings (No 15) | breeding_parent_named | Raised from seed; group consisted of twenty-five trees selected by J. G. Tyler (1880).
Tyler Seedlings (No 15) | entry_location | Seedlings raised at Hartford Township, Minnehaha County, South Dakota.
Tyler Seedlings (No 15) | selection_origin_reference | No. 15 attributed to introduction by D. F. Harrington of Sioux Falls, South Dakota.
University (Duchess No. 103) | breeder_reference | Bred/raised by C. G. Patten, Charles City, Iowa.
University (Duchess No. 103) | description_snippet | Entry is Duchess-derived and appears to continue onto adjacent pages for additional descriptor completion.
University (Duchess No. 103) | fruit_color | Surface described as clear yellow with orange-yellow on sunny side and minute white dots.
University (Duchess No. 103) | fruit_size | Fruit described as large and oblate, very regular.

Figures Removed

none

Citations Removed

Hansen, N.E., "A Study of Northwestern Apples," Bulletin Paper 76.

Available Page Versions

ID	Variant	Status	Model	Specialization	Counts	Source	Compare
1668	archivist-1.6.68-spark	active	gpt-5.3-codex-spark	visual_page_generalist	6 cultivars / 27 claims / 0 figures	Open source page
608	archivist-1.0	baseline_promoted	gpt-5.4	visual_page_generalist	6 cultivars / 26 claims / 0 figures	Open source page	Compare to active