Dashboard Explore Search Sources Source Graph Ingest Rights Review Translations Translation QA Publish Review Publish Export Revisit Campaigns History History Conflicts History Arbitration Review Queue Charts Taxa Taxonomy Tree Cultivars Lineage Lab Climate Breeders Institutions Programs Compare Compare Tray Trait Matrix Names Nurseries Nurseries+Catalogs Catalog Issues Archivist Resolution Contradictions Arbitration About API Docs

Archivist Page Review

Review parser variants for one source page, compare outputs, and jump directly to the source evidence.

Document: 14 A Study of Northwestern Apples

Source page: Open page 134 in document reader

Institution: Open PRAIRIE | Publisher: | Year: | Pages: 144

Source URL: https://openprairie.sdstate.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1075&context=agexperimentsta_bulletins

Selected Versions

Left: archivist-1.6.68-spark (fragment 5779)

Right: archivist-1.0 (fragment 3458)

Next Step

Reprocess/promote controls are the next UI layer. The data foundation is now versioned and diffable.

Page Version Diff

Cultivars Added
  • none
Claims Added
  • Haas | entry_hardiness_observation | Haas is deficient in hardiness for the north.
  • Haas | growth_habit | Haas is a strong grower.
  • Hibernal | entry_hardiness_observation | The winter of 1898-99 abruptly checked this line of work with Hibernal because of root-killing of the apple seedling stocks on which the trees were root-grafted and because of winter-killing of the y
  • Hibernal | recommendation_context | Hibernal apple was among the varieties most favored as stocks at the time of writing.
  • Hibernal | selection_origin_reference | Many trees of Hibernal were planted on the station grounds in spring 1896 as part of the stock experiment.
  • Oldenburg | description_snippet | Oldenburg is described just before the section as cosmopolitan in range and successful over a wide area and in many soils.
  • Oldenburg | rootstock_compatibility | Oldenburg apple had been used as a stock for top-working.
  • Virginia Crab | entry_hardiness_observation | Virginia crab trees survived because the scion roots proved hardy.
  • Virginia Crab | recommendation_context | Virginia crab was among the varieties most favored as stocks at the time of writing.
  • Virginia Crab | selection_origin_reference | Many trees of Virginia crab were planted on the station grounds in spring 1896 as part of this line of experimentation.
  • Whitney | rootstock_compatibility | Whitney had been used as a stock for top-working.
Figures Added
  • none
Citations Added
  • none
Cultivars Removed
  • Anisim
Claims Removed
  • Anisim | entry_location | Included in the 1896 station planting that paired multiple varieties for top-working evaluation.
  • Anisim | hardiness_observation | This trial line involving Anisim was curtailed after winter 1898-99, with young scion roots reported as winter-killed.
  • Anisim | recommendation_context | Not presented as a currently favored top-working stock in comparison with Virginia crab and Hibernal.
  • Haas | hardiness_observation | Described as a strong grower but not sufficiently hardy for northern conditions.
  • Haas | recommendation_context | Not presented as one of the favored top-working stocks for northern use.
  • Hibernal | entry_location | Planted on station grounds in spring 1896 as part of the top-working trial line with Virginia crab and Anisim.
  • Hibernal | hardiness_observation | Performance line was disrupted after winter 1898-99 due root stock and young scion root kill.
  • Hibernal | rootstock_compatibility | Listed as one of the most favored top-working stocks in this period.
  • Oldenburg | recommendation_context | Not among the presently favored stocks for top-working due to compatibility and union/split risk.
  • Oldenburg | rootstock_compatibility | Used as a stock for top-working, but generally unfavorable because many sorts overgrow the stock and may split the union, increasing blow-off risk.
  • Virginia Crab | entry_location | Included in station-grown top-working trees under test in the 1896 planting line.
  • Virginia Crab | hardiness_observation | Survived severe winter stress in this trial line because scion roots proved hardy.
  • Virginia Crab | rootstock_compatibility | One of the varieties most favored as top-working stock at this stage.
  • Whitney | recommendation_context | Not among the varieties most favored at this stage for continued top-working stock use.
  • Whitney | rootstock_compatibility | Whitney has been tried as top-working stock but performs poorly in this context; stock overgrowth and union enlargement were reported.
Figures Removed
  • none
Citations Removed
  • none

Available Page Versions

IDVariantStatusModelSpecializationCountsSourceCompare
1694archivist-1.6.68-sparkactivegpt-5.3-codex-sparkvisual_page_generalist6 cultivars / 15 claims / 0 figuresOpen source page
634archivist-1.0baseline_promotedgpt-5.4visual_page_generalist5 cultivars / 11 claims / 0 figuresOpen source pageCompare to active