Dashboard Explore Search Sources Source Graph Ingest Rights Review Translations Translation QA Publish Review Publish Export Revisit Campaigns History History Conflicts History Arbitration Review Queue Charts Taxa Taxonomy Tree Cultivars Lineage Lab Climate Breeders Institutions Programs Compare Compare Tray Trait Matrix Names Nurseries Nurseries+Catalogs Catalog Issues Archivist Resolution Contradictions Arbitration About API Docs

Archivist Page Review

Review parser variants for one source page, compare outputs, and jump directly to the source evidence.

Document: 17 Plums in South Dakota

Source page: Open page 23 in document reader

Institution: Open PRAIRIE | Publisher: | Year: | Pages: 89

Source URL: https://openprairie.sdstate.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1092&context=agexperimentsta_bulletins

Selected Versions

Left: archivist-1.0 (fragment 3595)

Right: archivist-1.0 (fragment 10801)

Next Step

Reprocess/promote controls are the next UI layer. The data foundation is now versioned and diffable.

Page Version Diff

Cultivars Added
  • none
Claims Added
  • Lombard | entry_pedigree | Stated explicitly as an old variety; no explicit hybrid parentage provided in this entry.
  • Lombard | growth_habit | Two station trees on sand cherry stock showed good growth after planting in 1900.
  • Lombard | hardiness_code_expansion | Noted as not sufficiently hardy for the prairie north, but still cultivated in the station trials.
  • Lombard | productivity | Station trials indicate acceptable crop/bearing performance relative to nearby entries in the same section.
  • Lombard | selection_origin_reference | Origin listed as New York, with historical use as a common European plum type in cultivation.
  • Manitoba No. 1 | description_snippet | Bears when approximately three feet tall and is considered valuable for extreme earliness.
  • Manitoba No. 1 | description_snippet | Ripe windows on this page include statements for mid-August, and evaluator notes report ripe dates from August 1st to 10th.
  • Manitoba No. 1 | entry_location | Observed and evaluated at the South Dakota Experiment Station.
  • Manitoba No. 1 | flavor_profile | A. Norby notes include firm flesh and freestone characteristics; pit free is noted in evaluator remarks.
  • Manitoba No. 1 | fruit_color | Fruit described as rich bright red.
  • Manitoba No. 1 | fruit_size | Fruit described as medium size; later notes report fruit about one to one and one-eighth inches (to one and three-eighths inches in later evaluator comments).
  • Manitoba No. 1 | keeping_quality | Described as a good keeper.
  • Manitoba No. 1 | productivity | Evaluator notes describe it as a slow grower and good bearer, with annual bearing in later quotes.
  • Manitoba No. 1 | productivity | Noted as very productive.
  • Manitoba No. 1 | selection_origin_reference | Identified as a wild variety from Manitoba.
  • Manitoba Seedlings | entry_location | Material explicitly said to have been grown at the South Dakota Experiment Station.
  • Manitoba Seedlings | recommendation_context | Introduced as a separate heading indicating mixed seedling-type entries rather than a single single-cultivar profile.
  • Manitoba Seedlings | selection_origin_reference | Class headed as a group of seedlings, originating from wild pits received from Manitoba.
Figures Added
  • none
Citations Added
  • A. Norby evaluations on Manitoba No. 1 (1902, 1903, 1904).
  • Hansen, N. E., "Plums in South Dakota," South Dakota State Agricultural College Bulletin 93 (1905).
Cultivars Removed
  • none
Claims Removed
  • Lombard | growth_habit | The trees on sand cherry stock made a good growth.
  • Lombard | productivity | The station trees on sand cherry stock bore well in 1904 for the size of tree.
  • Lombard | recommendation_context | It was one of the most commonly grown European plums, but not sufficiently hardy in the prairie northwest.
  • Lombard | rootstock_compatibility | Fair specimens at the station were grown crown-grafted in a wild plum thicket.
  • Lombard | rootstock_compatibility | Two Lombard trees on sand cherry stock grown at the station and planted in 1900 made a good growth and bore well in 1904 for the size of tree.
  • Lombard | selection_origin_reference | An old variety originated in New York.
  • Lombard | taxon_context | Listed as domestica, identifying it as a European plum.
  • Manitoba No. 1 | anecdote_snippet | A. Norby reported it blooms a little later than Aitkin and ripens August 10th, the earliest variety fruited there.
  • Manitoba No. 1 | anecdote_snippet | By 1904 it was said to bear every year and to have developed no bad qualities so far.
  • Manitoba No. 1 | culinary_use | Cooks well.
  • Manitoba No. 1 | description_snippet | A. Norby described the flesh as firm and a perfect freestone, though not free from pockets.
  • Manitoba No. 1 | description_snippet | Fruit ripe 15th to 20th of August.
  • Manitoba No. 1 | description_snippet | Fruit was described as round, beautiful, with firm meat and pit free.
  • Manitoba No. 1 | description_snippet | Later notes say it ripens from August 1st to 10th, at least a week earlier than any other variety there.
  • Manitoba No. 1 | description_snippet | Remarkable for bearing fruit on very young trees not over three feet in height.
  • Manitoba No. 1 | description_snippet | Skin rather thick and bitter.
  • Manitoba No. 1 | entry_location | A wild variety from Manitoba.
  • Manitoba No. 1 | fruit_color | A. Norby described the fruit as bright red and attractive.
  • Manitoba No. 1 | fruit_color | Color rich bright red.
  • Manitoba No. 1 | fruit_size | A. Norby reported size as about one and one-eighth inch in diameter.
Figures Removed
  • none
Citations Removed
  • A. Norby observations (1902, 1903, 1904)

Available Page Versions

IDVariantStatusModelSpecializationCountsSourceCompare
765archivist-1.0activegpt-5.4visual_page_generalist3 cultivars / 32 claims / 0 figuresOpen source page
3281archivist-1.0candidategpt-5.4visual_page_generalist3 cultivars / 18 claims / 0 figuresOpen source pageCompare to active