Dashboard Explore Search Sources Source Graph Ingest Rights Review Translations Translation QA Publish Review Publish Export Revisit Campaigns History History Conflicts History Arbitration Review Queue Charts Taxa Taxonomy Tree Cultivars Lineage Lab Climate Breeders Institutions Programs Compare Compare Tray Trait Matrix Names Nurseries Nurseries+Catalogs Catalog Issues Archivist Resolution Contradictions Arbitration About API Docs

Archivist Page Review

Review parser variants for one source page, compare outputs, and jump directly to the source evidence.

Document: 17 Plums in South Dakota

Source page: Open page 40 in document reader

Institution: Open PRAIRIE | Publisher: | Year: | Pages: 89

Source URL: https://openprairie.sdstate.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1092&context=agexperimentsta_bulletins

Selected Versions

Left: archivist-1.0 (fragment 3612)

Right: archivist-1.0 (fragment 10823)

Next Step

Reprocess/promote controls are the next UI layer. The data foundation is now versioned and diffable.

Page Version Diff

Cultivars Added
  • none
Claims Added
  • Stoddard | entry_hardiness_observation | Noted by A. Norby as not as hardy as most of the Americana group.
  • Stoddard | fruit_color | Fruit color noted as darker red than Hawkeye in comparison.
  • Stoddard | fruit_ripening | Reported ripe around September 12 in 1903 and September 15 in 1904.
  • Stoddard | fruit_size | Fruit described as very large, showy, and nearly round; one evaluator gave average size around one and three-eighths inches.
  • Stoddard | keeping_quality | A good keeper according to Haralson remarks.
  • Stoddard | productivity | Reported as a light cropper in at least one year and generally considered a market-worthy variety despite later ripening in this latitude.
  • Stoddard | recommendation_context | Haralson described Stoddard as a promising variety.
  • Stoddard | release_year_reference | Introduced in 1890 by John Wragg & Son.
  • Stoddard | selection_origin_reference | Associated with B.F. Stoddard, Waukee, Iowa; introduced through John Wragg & Son.
  • Stoddard | selection_origin_reference | Cultivar trials were established in the station orchard beginning in 1896.
  • Stoddard | source_reference_abbreviation | Evaluator citation appears as "Mr. Haralson notes"; this is a direct trial observer note, not a formal varietal-standard code.
  • Surprise | entry_pedigree | Botanical characteristics in this document indicate miner parentage.
  • Surprise | flavor_profile | Flesh reported as firm and sweet.
  • Surprise | fruit_color | Fruit color noted as bright red with thin skin.
  • Surprise | fruit_ripening | Ripening dates reported as September 7 in 1903 and September 10 in 1904.
  • Surprise | fruit_size | Fruit described as large and nearly egg-shaped.
  • Surprise | growth_habit | Tree described as handsome with upright, well-distributed limbs; advised to receive light training when young for compact habit.
  • Surprise | productivity | Station trees were strong growers; one-year grafted trees began bearing in 1903 and produced a heavy crop in 1904.
  • Surprise | recommendation_context | Concluded as "very good" in the station narrative.
  • Surprise | release_year_reference | Introduced in 1899.
Figures Added
  • none
Citations Added
  • Hansen, N.E. "Plums in South Dakota" (1905). Bulletins. Paper 93.
  • Haralson (observer remarks), A. Norby (observer remarks).
Cultivars Removed
  • none
Claims Removed
  • Stoddard | description_snippet | Fruit is showy and of good quality.
  • Stoddard | description_snippet | Mr. Haralson noted: resembles the J. B. Rue both in tree and fruit; a good keeper; a very promising variety.
  • Stoddard | description_snippet | Rather late for this latitude.
  • Stoddard | entry_hardiness_observation | A. Norby reported it was not as hardy as most of the Americana family.
  • Stoddard | entry_hardiness_observation | Another note says the tree is hardy there but will not stand as far north as DeSoto or Wyant.
  • Stoddard | flavor_profile | A. Norby described the fruit as of fair quality and lacking attractive color.
  • Stoddard | fruit_color | It resembles Hawkeye but is a little earlier and darker red in color.
  • Stoddard | fruit_size | A. Norby reported the fruit averages large, about one and three-eighths inches.
  • Stoddard | fruit_size | Fruit averages as large as any variety fruited in the orchard.
  • Stoddard | fruit_size | Fruit very large and nearly round.
  • Stoddard | growth_habit | Tree of good habit, abundantly productive.
  • Stoddard | growth_habit | Trees planted in 1896 at the Station are in excellent condition.
  • Stoddard | productivity | A. Norby reported a good crop.
  • Stoddard | productivity | It is described as a light cropper.
  • Stoddard | productivity | It is sufficiently productive and quite free from pockets.
  • Stoddard | recommendation_context | Although lacking high color and quality, it brings the highest price in market and is called a valuable variety.
  • Stoddard | recommendation_context | It was considered fully tested and valuable for market, although quality is rather below average.
  • Stoddard | release_year_reference | A note states it ripens August 25 there.
  • Stoddard | release_year_reference | A. Norby reported it ripe September 4 in 1902.
  • Stoddard | release_year_reference | At the Station the fruit was ripe September 12 in 1903 and September 15 in 1904.
Figures Removed
  • none
Citations Removed
  • none

Available Page Versions

IDVariantStatusModelSpecializationCountsSourceCompare
782archivist-1.0activegpt-5.4visual_page_generalist2 cultivars / 38 claims / 0 figuresOpen source page
3297archivist-1.0candidategpt-5.4visual_page_generalist2 cultivars / 21 claims / 0 figuresOpen source pageCompare to active