Dashboard Explore Search Sources Source Graph Ingest Rights Review Translations Translation QA Publish Review Publish Export Revisit Campaigns History History Conflicts History Arbitration Review Queue Charts Taxa Taxonomy Tree Cultivars Lineage Lab Climate Breeders Institutions Programs Compare Compare Tray Trait Matrix Names Nurseries Nurseries+Catalogs Catalog Issues Archivist Resolution Contradictions Arbitration About API Docs

Archivist Page Review

Review parser variants for one source page, compare outputs, and jump directly to the source evidence.

Document: 3 Edible Apples in Prairie Canada

Source page: Open page 36 in document reader

Institution: University of Saskatchewan Fruit Program | Publisher: | Year: | Pages: 79

Source URL: https://research-groups.usask.ca/fruit/documents/apples/Edible-Apples-in-Prairie-Canada1.pdf

Selected Versions

Left: archivist-1.2-dense-directory-codebook (fragment 5611)

Right: archivist-1.1-dense-directory (fragment 4209)

Next Step

Reprocess/promote controls are the next UI layer. The data foundation is now versioned and diffable.

Page Version Diff

Cultivars Added
  • none
Claims Added
  • Herald | entry_pedigree | Listed as a Fameuse seedling.
  • Herald | recommendation_context | Entry is marked "ST" in the right margin.
  • Herald | source_reference_abbreviation | Cited as "CEF (1910) M.B. Davis."
  • Herald | source_reference_abbreviation | Reference note includes "Ref Wisc. Smithfield. FB1."
  • Hermansky | description_snippet | Resembles Wagener in shape and taste.
  • Hermansky | entry_pedigree | Listed as a McIntosh seedling.
  • Hermansky | keeping_quality | Late; fair keeper.
  • Hermansky | recommendation_context | Entry is marked "ST" in the right margin.
  • Hermansky | release_year_reference | Associated with Hermansky (1965).
  • Hermansky | source_reference_abbreviation | Referenced in Skinner's catalog (1986), F&N, and FB1.
  • Hermanson | description_snippet | Fruit crisp and juicy.
  • Hermanson | source_reference_abbreviation | Referenced in Boughen's catalog (1984).
  • Heyer #12 | culinary_use | Too sour for use as a dessert apple but fine for cooking.
  • Heyer #12 | description_snippet | "Obsolete. A fair breeder," says Coutts (1991).
  • Heyer #12 | description_snippet | Drops badly while ripening.
  • Heyer #12 | description_snippet | Very early.
  • Heyer #12 | entry_pedigree | Listed as a Russian apple seedling.
  • Heyer #12 | fruit_color | Green-yellow fruit.
  • Heyer #12 | fruit_size | Fruit 6 cm.
  • Heyer #12 | keeping_quality | Breaks down quickly after ripening, so should be picked just before fruit turns yellow.
Figures Added
  • none
Citations Added
  • Erskine rec.
  • Manchester
  • Rosthern test (1930s H2-3)
Cultivars Removed
  • none
Claims Removed
  • Herald | breeder_reference | The entry cites CEF (1910) and M.B. Davis, indicating Central Experimental Farm association and a 1910 reference year.
  • Herald | description_snippet | Listed as a standard apple (standard apple, fruit 5 cm diameter or more).
  • Herald | entry_location | Smithfield is cited in the entry, likely referring to Smithfield Experimental Farm, Trenton, Ontario, as defined in the document legend.
  • Herald | entry_pedigree | Herald is identified as a Fameuse seedling.
  • Herald | fruit_size | Classed as ST, meaning a standard apple with fruit 5 cm diameter or more.
  • Herald | source_reference_abbreviation | FB1 is cited as a fireblight-related rating code from the document legend context.
  • Herald | source_reference_abbreviation | Reference cited: WCSH, expanded in the document legend as Western Canadian Society for Horticulture.
  • Herald | source_reference_abbreviation | References cited: WCSH (Western Canadian Society for Horticulture (1944- ).).
  • Hermansky | description_snippet | Fruit resembles Wagener in shape and taste.
  • Hermansky | description_snippet | Listed as a standard apple (standard apple, fruit 5 cm diameter or more).
  • Hermansky | entry_pedigree | Hermansky is identified as a McIntosh seedling.
  • Hermansky | fruit_size | Classed as ST, meaning a standard apple with fruit 5 cm diameter or more.
  • Hermansky | keeping_quality | It is late and a fair keeper.
  • Hermansky | release_year_reference | The entry associates Hermansky with 1965.
  • Hermansky | source_reference_abbreviation | FB1 is cited as a fireblight-related rating code from the document legend context.
  • Hermansky | source_reference_abbreviation | References cited: Skinner's catalog (1986) and F&N.
  • Hermanson | source_reference_abbreviation | Reference cited: Boughen's catalog (1984).
  • Hermanson | texture | Fruit is crisp and juicy.
  • Heyer #12 | breeder_reference | Coutts (1991) says: obsolete and a fair breeder.
  • Heyer #12 | culinary_use | Too tart for dessert use but fine for cooking.
Figures Removed
  • none
Citations Removed
  • Bart Hall-Beyer and Richard, Ecological Fruit Production in the North (1983)
  • Hort Guide 1952

Available Page Versions

IDVariantStatusModelSpecializationCountsSourceCompare
1532archivist-1.2-dense-directory-codebookactivegpt-5.4dense_directory_entry_list11 cultivars / 115 claims / 0 figuresOpen source page
1211archivist-1.1-dense-directorycandidategpt-5.4dense_directory_entry_list11 cultivars / 84 claims / 0 figuresOpen source pageCompare to active
71archivist-1.0baseline_promotedgpt-5.4visual_page_generalist11 cultivars / 62 claims / 0 figuresOpen source pageCompare to active