Archivist Page Review

Review parser variants for one source page, compare outputs, and jump directly to the source evidence.

Document: 14 A Study of Northwestern Apples

Source page: Open page 52 in document reader

Institution: Open PRAIRIE | Publisher: | Year: | Pages: 144

Source URL: https://openprairie.sdstate.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1075&context=agexperimentsta_bulletins

Selected Versions

Left: archivist-1.6.68-spark (fragment 5713)

Right: archivist-1.0 (fragment 3376)

Next Step

Reprocess/promote controls are the next UI layer. The data foundation is now versioned and diffable.

Page Version Diff

Cultivars Added

none

Claims Added

Giant Swaar | description_snippet | Calyx closed with small connivent segments; core wide open; cells abaxile, ovate, slit; tube conical; stamens basal; seeds very plump.
Giant Swaar | description_snippet | Cavity regular and deep, with a very large russet patch extending out over base; stem short; basin very shallow, narrow, nearly smooth, with minute wrinkles.
Giant Swaar | entry_location | Specimens were from J. S. Harris, LaCrescent, Minnesota.
Giant Swaar | flavor_profile | Flesh snow white, very juicy, sprightly refreshing subacid, good.
Giant Swaar | fruit_color | Surface clear waxen yellow, somewhat polished, with many minute green dots and a few large russet specks.
Giant Swaar | fruit_size | Fruit large, very regular, roundish, somewhat conical.
Giant Swaar | recommendation_context | Season given as September.
Gideon | breeder_reference | Originated by the late Peter M. Gideon, Excelsior, Minnesota.
Gideon | description_snippet | Cavity wide, medium deep; stem medium to long; basin wide, shallow, somewhat corrugated; calyx closed.
Gideon | description_snippet | Core large, half open, clasping; cells obovate, slit; tube funnel-shaped; stamens marginal; seeds few, large, flattened, long, pointed.
Gideon | flavor_profile | Flesh white, juicy, brisk subacid, good.
Gideon | fruit_color | Surface a clear yellowish white, with faint bronze blush, an attractive color; dots white, suffused, numerous, minute, distinct.
Gideon | fruit_size | Fruit large, roundish oblong conical, regular, slightly ribbed.
Gideon | recommendation_context | Season given as late fall.
Gipsy Girl | caption_context | A cut illustration on the page is labeled Gipsy Girl.
Gipsy Girl | description_snippet | Dots distinct, few, minute, white; cavity regular, acute, with stellate russet; stem short; basin wide, rather shallow, angular.
Gipsy Girl | entry_hardiness_observation | One of the hardiest, most vigorous and productive of the Russian apples at Ottawa, Canada.
Gipsy Girl | entry_location | Origin, Russia.
Gipsy Girl | fruit_color | Surface very highly colored, a clear light waxen yellow, almost wholly covered with bright, solid dark crimson on sunny side; on shady side the crimson is thinly marbled and mottled like a water colored painting.
Gipsy Girl | fruit_size | Fruit above medium to large, irregular, oblate, angular.

Figures Added

none

Citations Added

none

Cultivars Removed

none

Claims Removed

Giant Swaar | description_snippet | Cavity regular and deep; large russet patch over base; stem short; basin very shallow, narrow, nearly smooth; calyx closed and connivent; core wide open; cells ovate/slit; tube conical; stamens basal; see
Giant Swaar | entry_pedigree | Giant Swaar is recorded as specimens from J. S. Harris, LaCrescent, Minnesota.
Giant Swaar | flavor_profile | Flesh is snow white, very juicy, sprightly refreshing subacid, and marked good.
Giant Swaar | fruit_color | Skin is clear waxen yellow, somewhat polished, with many minute green dots and a few large russet specks.
Giant Swaar | fruit_size | Fruit described as large, regular, roundish, somewhat conical.
Giant Swaar | storage_duration | Harvest/season noted as September.
Gideon | breeder_reference | Attribution given to the late Peter M. Gideon, Excelsior, Minnesota.
Gideon | description_snippet | Cavity wide/medium deep; stem medium to long; basin wide, shallow, somewhat corrugated; calyx closed; core large and half-open clasping; seeds few, large, flattened, long, pointed.
Gideon | flavor_profile | Flesh is white, juicy, brisk subacid, with good quality noted.
Gideon | fruit_color | Skin described as clear yellowish white with faint bronze blush.
Gideon | fruit_size | Fruit is described as large, roundish oblong, conical, regular, slightly ribbed.
Gideon | storage_duration | Noted season: Late fall.
Gipsy Girl | description_snippet | Cavity regular and acute with stellate russet; stem short; basin wide, shallow, angular; calyx closed; core details begin in this page and continue.
Gipsy Girl | entry_hardiness_observation | Described as one of the hardiest, most vigorous, and productive Russian apples at Ottawa, Canada.
Gipsy Girl | entry_location | Origin stated as Russia, with regional performance notes for Ottawa, Canada, and Des Moines, Iowa.
Gipsy Girl | fruit_color | Skin is clear light waxen yellow with very high dark crimson striping on sunny side; marbled and mottled on shady side; dots distinct, few, minute, white.
Gipsy Girl | fruit_size | Fruit above medium to large; shape irregular, oblate, angular.
Gipsy Girl | productivity | Explicitly described as highly vigorous and productive.
Gipsy Girl | storage_duration | Described as a fall apple at Des Moines, Iowa.
Gipsy Girl | storage_duration | Noted to keep till February in Ottawa, Canada.

Figures Removed

none

Citations Removed

Hansen, N.E. (1902). A Study of Northwestern Apples. South Dakota State University Agricultural Experiment Station. Paper 76.

Available Page Versions

ID	Variant	Status	Model	Specialization	Counts	Source	Compare
1630	archivist-1.6.68-spark	active	gpt-5.3-codex-spark	visual_page_generalist	3 cultivars / 20 claims / 0 figures	Open source page
552	archivist-1.0	baseline_promoted	gpt-5.4	visual_page_generalist	3 cultivars / 22 claims / 0 figures	Open source page	Compare to active