Archivist Page Review

Review parser variants for one source page, compare outputs, and jump directly to the source evidence.

Document: 15 The Western Sand Cherry

Source page: Open page 52 in document reader

Institution: Open PRAIRIE | Publisher: | Year: | Pages: 65

Source URL: https://openprairie.sdstate.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1086&context=agexperimentsta_bulletins

Selected Versions

Left: archivist-1.0 (fragment 3522)

Right: archivist-1.0 (fragment 11239)

Next Step

Reprocess/promote controls are the next UI layer. The data foundation is now versioned and diffable.

Page Version Diff

Cultivars Added

Desoto

Claims Added

Desoto | anecdote_snippet | The page preserves the adverse report but explicitly corrects it: the trees were later found not to be on Sand Cherry roots, so the negative result should not be attributed to Sand Cherry stock.
Desoto | flavor_profile | The quoted adverse note says the fruit was of inferior quality and about worthless, but the page identifies the underlying rootstock observation as erroneous.
Desoto | fruit_size | The quoted adverse note says the fruit was found to be of inferior size, but the page later states the trees were subsequently found not to be on Sand Cherry roots.
Desoto | productivity | The quoted note reports that some of the grafted trees fruited in 1897 and all fruited in 1898, but it does not separate the observation by cultivar.
Desoto | rootstock_compatibility | A note quoted from Minnesota Horticulturist, January 1899, names DeSoto among scions used when the writer believed plum had been grafted on Sand Cherry.
Rockford | anecdote_snippet | The page preserves the adverse report but explicitly corrects it: the trees were later found not to be on Sand Cherry roots, so the negative result should not be attributed to Sand Cherry stock.
Rockford | flavor_profile | The quoted adverse note says the fruit was of inferior quality and about worthless, but the page identifies the underlying rootstock observation as erroneous.
Rockford | fruit_size | The quoted adverse note says the fruit was found to be of inferior size, but the page later states the trees were subsequently found not to be on Sand Cherry roots.
Rockford | productivity | The quoted note reports that some of the grafted trees fruited in 1897 and all fruited in 1898, but it does not separate the observation by cultivar.
Rockford | rootstock_compatibility | A note quoted from Minnesota Horticulturist, January 1899, names Rockford among scions used when the writer believed plum had been grafted on Sand Cherry.
Wolf | anecdote_snippet | The page preserves the adverse report but explicitly corrects it: the trees were later found not to be on Sand Cherry roots, so the negative result should not be attributed to Sand Cherry stock.
Wolf | flavor_profile | The quoted adverse note says the fruit was of inferior quality and about worthless, but the page identifies the underlying rootstock observation as erroneous.
Wolf | fruit_size | The quoted adverse note says the fruit was found to be of inferior size, but the page later states the trees were subsequently found not to be on Sand Cherry roots.
Wolf | productivity | The quoted note reports that some of the grafted trees fruited in 1897 and all fruited in 1898, but it does not separate the observation by cultivar.
Wolf | rootstock_compatibility | A note quoted from Minnesota Horticulturist, January 1899, names Wolf among scions used when the writer believed plum had been grafted on Sand Cherry.
Wyant | anecdote_snippet | The page preserves the adverse report but explicitly corrects it: the trees were later found not to be on Sand Cherry roots, so the negative result should not be attributed to Sand Cherry stock.
Wyant | flavor_profile | The quoted adverse note says the fruit was of inferior quality and about worthless, but the page identifies the underlying rootstock observation as erroneous.
Wyant | fruit_size | The quoted adverse note says the fruit was found to be of inferior size, but the page later states the trees were subsequently found not to be on Sand Cherry roots.
Wyant | productivity | The quoted note reports that some of the grafted trees fruited in 1897 and all fruited in 1898, but it does not separate the observation by cultivar.
Wyant | rootstock_compatibility | A note quoted from Minnesota Horticulturist, January 1899, names Wyant among scions used when the writer believed plum had been grafted on Sand Cherry.

Figures Added

none

Citations Added

M. J. Wragg, Waukee, Iowa, letter dated January 23, 1901

Cultivars Removed

De Soto

Claims Removed

De Soto | description_snippet | The trees in that adverse note were later said to have been not on Sand Cherry roots at all, but misobserved.
De Soto | fruit_size | The adverse note said the fruit was of inferior size.
De Soto | productivity | The adverse note stated that some of the trees fruited in 1897 and all of them fruited in 1898.
De Soto | rootstock_compatibility | An 1899 adverse note stated that plum grafted on Sand Cherry using scions including De Soto had produced fruit judged of inferior size and quality.
Rockford | description_snippet | The trees in that adverse note were later said to have been not on Sand Cherry roots at all, but misobserved.
Rockford | fruit_size | The adverse note said the fruit was of inferior size.
Rockford | productivity | The adverse note stated that some of the trees fruited in 1897 and all of them fruited in 1898.
Rockford | rootstock_compatibility | An 1899 adverse note stated that plum grafted on Sand Cherry using scions including Rockford had produced fruit judged of inferior size and quality.
Wolf | description_snippet | The trees in that adverse note were later said to have been not on Sand Cherry roots at all, but misobserved.
Wolf | fruit_size | The adverse note said the fruit was of inferior size.
Wolf | productivity | The adverse note stated that some of the trees fruited in 1897 and all of them fruited in 1898.
Wolf | rootstock_compatibility | An 1899 adverse note stated that plum grafted on Sand Cherry using scions including Wolf had produced fruit judged of inferior size and quality.
Wyant | description_snippet | The trees in that adverse note were later said to have been not on Sand Cherry roots at all, but misobserved.
Wyant | fruit_size | The adverse note said the fruit was of inferior size.
Wyant | productivity | The adverse note stated that some of the trees fruited in 1897 and all of them fruited in 1898.
Wyant | rootstock_compatibility | An 1899 adverse note stated that plum grafted on Sand Cherry using scions including Wyant had produced fruit judged of inferior size and quality.

Figures Removed

none

Citations Removed

Letter from M. J. Wragg, Waukee, Iowa, under date of January 23, 1901
Mr. Penning report under date of May 26th, 1904

Available Page Versions

ID	Variant	Status	Model	Specialization	Counts	Source	Compare
696	archivist-1.0	active	gpt-5.4	visual_page_generalist	4 cultivars / 16 claims / 0 figures	Open source page
3570	archivist-1.0	candidate	gpt-5.4	visual_page_generalist	4 cultivars / 20 claims / 0 figures	Open source page	Compare to active