Archivist Page Review

Review parser variants for one source page, compare outputs, and jump directly to the source evidence.

Document: 17 Plums in South Dakota

Source page: Open page 27 in document reader

Institution: Open PRAIRIE | Publisher: | Year: | Pages: 89

Source URL: https://openprairie.sdstate.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1092&context=agexperimentsta_bulletins

Selected Versions

Left: archivist-1.0 (fragment 3599)

Right: archivist-1.0 (fragment 10807)

Next Step

Reprocess/promote controls are the next UI layer. The data foundation is now versioned and diffable.

Page Version Diff

Cultivars Added

Moidavka

Claims Added

Miner | culinary_use | Miner's late ripening is described as useful for canning in cool fall weather.
Miner | description_snippet | At Brookings, plants are in poor-to-fair condition and are described as a light bearer.
Miner | entry_hardiness_observation | The page reports nursery shoots from graft or bud kill back severely after first winter, interpreted as limited hardiness, and fruit at Brookings is often frost-late, reducing quality.
Miner | entry_location | In South Dakota, Miner is observed mainly along the Missouri River region of the southeast, with documented planting at Vermillion and Yankton.
Miner | productivity | General experience is that Miner is not productive when planted alone; mixed planting (e.g., with Forest Garden) is preferred.
Miner | recommendation_context | A stated planting guideline uses a ratio of two Miner trees to one Forest Garden tree in mixed orchard settings.
Miner | recommendation_context | The cultivar is noted as not appearing on the Minnesota State Horticultural Society recommended fruit list.
Moidavka | breeder_reference | Attributed to introduction from Prof. J. L. Budd.
Moidavka | entry_hardiness_observation | Not proven hardy in the old station orchard, where trees are reported as dead.
Moidavka | entry_location | Observed in the Wells orchard at Spearfish (Black Hills region) as performing better than in the old station orchard.
Moidavka | flavor_profile | Fruit described as of excellent quality.
Moidavka | fruit_color | Fruit color described as yellow.
Moidavka | fruit_size | Fruit described as large.
Moidavka | selection_origin_reference | Reported as imported from Russia by Professor J. L. Budd.
Moidavka | source_reference_abbreviation | The note indicates acquisition "from the introducer" directly about ten years prior to observation.
New American | description_snippet | Its value is limited by maturity timing rather than reported tree defects; no productive-use value is indicated in the old station orchard.
New American | entry_hardiness_observation | The cultivar is marked as unhelpful commercially because it is too late in season in station conditions.
New American | productivity | Characterized as too late in season to be of any value at this station.
New Ulm | breeder_reference | Introduced by C. W. Heide man (Minnesota).
New Ulm | fruit_size | Recommended historically for large size.

Figures Added

none

Citations Added

Hansen, N.E., "Plums in South Dakota" (1905), Bulletin.
Minnesota State Horticultural Society, recommended fruit list (1904 annual meeting note).

Cultivars Removed

Moldavka

Claims Removed

Miner | culinary_use | Miner comes in during the cool weather in the fall when housewives prefer to can plums.
Miner | description_snippet | Forest Garden was valued for earliness and productiveness, while Miner was considered more valuable because of its late ripening.
Miner | entry_hardiness_observation | At Brookings the fruit ripens too late to be of any value in average seasons, being caught by frost before acquiring sweetness.
Miner | entry_hardiness_observation | In nursery row one-year shoots from the graft or bud kill back severely the first winter, showing inherent lack of hardiness.
Miner | entry_location | As far as South Dakota is concerned the northern limit of this variety is along the Missouri River in the southeastern part of the state.
Miner | entry_location | At Vermillion and Yankton this variety has been planted extensively in mixed orchards with Forest Garden.
Miner | entry_location | In the old Station orchard at Brookings the trees are in poor to fair condition.
Miner | productivity | A light bearer at Brookings.
Miner | productivity | Miner is not productive when planted by itself in the orchard and should be intermingled with other varieties.
Miner | recommendation_context | At Vermillion and Yankton the proportion generally planted is two trees of Miner to one of Forest Garden.
Miner | recommendation_context | Not found on the recommended fruit list of the Minnesota State Horticultural Society.
Moldavka | breeder_reference | Imported from Russia by Prof. J. L. Budd.
Moldavka | entry_hardiness_observation | This variety has not proven hardy in the old Station orchard and the trees are now dead.
Moldavka | entry_location | In the Wells orchard at Spearfish in the Black Hills region this variety was observed in the summer of 1904 to be doing well.
Moldavka | flavor_profile | The fruit is of excellent quality.
Moldavka | fruit_color | The fruit is yellow.
Moldavka | fruit_size | The fruit is large.
Moldavka | selection_origin_reference | Imported from Russia.
Moldavka | selection_origin_reference | The trees at Spearfish came from the introducer direct about ten years ago.
Moldavka | taxon_context | Classed as domestica.

Figures Removed

none

Citations Removed

recommended fruit list of the Minnesota State Horticultural Society

Available Page Versions

ID	Variant	Status	Model	Specialization	Counts	Source	Compare
769	archivist-1.0	active	gpt-5.4	visual_page_generalist	4 cultivars / 28 claims / 0 figures	Open source page
3285	archivist-1.0	candidate	gpt-5.4	visual_page_generalist	4 cultivars / 24 claims / 0 figures	Open source page	Compare to active