Dashboard Explore Search Sources Source Graph Ingest Rights Review Translations Translation QA Publish Review Publish Export Revisit Campaigns History History Conflicts History Arbitration Review Queue Charts Taxa Taxonomy Tree Cultivars Lineage Lab Climate Breeders Institutions Programs Compare Compare Tray Trait Matrix Names Nurseries Nurseries+Catalogs Catalog Issues Archivist Resolution Contradictions Arbitration About API Docs

Archivist Page Review

Review parser variants for one source page, compare outputs, and jump directly to the source evidence.

Document: 17 Plums in South Dakota

Source page: Open page 38 in document reader

Institution: Open PRAIRIE | Publisher: | Year: | Pages: 89

Source URL: https://openprairie.sdstate.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1092&context=agexperimentsta_bulletins

Selected Versions

Left: archivist-1.0 (fragment 3610)

Right: archivist-1.0 (fragment 10821)

Next Step

Reprocess/promote controls are the next UI layer. The data foundation is now versioned and diffable.

Page Version Diff

Cultivars Added
  • Smith Americana
  • Speer Americana
Claims Added
  • Smith Americana | comparative_value | Labeled not equal to De Soto in one 1904 note.
  • Smith Americana | description_snippet | Observed as ripening in early September with small and soft fruit in one set of observations.
  • Smith Americana | disease_issue | Noted as much injured by gouger, curculio, and rot in evaluator notes.
  • Smith Americana | fruit_size | Described as one of the largest plums of its class.
  • Smith Americana | productivity | Reported in 1902 as having small trees and a fair crop; in 1903 large but only fairly productive; in 1904 described as a good bearer.
  • Smith Americana | recommendation_context | This cultivar is noted as not in the Station orchard.
  • Smith Americana | selection_origin_reference | The entry was originated by C. A. Smith in Caroline County, Maryland, from seed of Quaker.
  • Speer Americana | anecdote_snippet | H. C. Warner in South Dakota reported this variety as too small in 1903.
  • Speer Americana | entry_hardiness_observation | Trees in the old Station orchard were observed to be hardy.
  • Speer Americana | fruit_size | Fruit is generally too small, with best-size specimens only medium or below.
  • Speer Americana | productivity | Entry was described as overbearing in the station orchard.
  • Speer Americana | selection_origin_reference | Described as a wild variety from J. A. Speer of Cedar Falls, Iowa.
  • Speer Americana | source_reference_abbreviation | The page references a 1903 report observation attributed to H. C. Warner from Forestburg, South Dakota.
Figures Added
  • none
Citations Added
  • Hansen, N.E., "Plums in South Dakota" (1905). Bulletins. Paper 93.
  • South Dakota State University, Open PRAIRIE institutional repository record for "Plums in South Dakota".
Cultivars Removed
  • Smith
  • Speer
Claims Removed
  • Smith | description_snippet | A. Norby reported in 1902: small trees and fair crop; ripe September 2nd; fruit quite soft.
  • Smith | description_snippet | In 1903 A. Norby reported it was much subject to curculio and gouger.
  • Smith | description_snippet | In 1904 A. Norby reported it was much injured by the gouger, curculio and rot.
  • Smith | description_snippet | Said to be one of the largest plums of its class.
  • Smith | entry_location | The variety originated in Caroline county, Maryland.
  • Smith | entry_pedigree | Originated by C. A. Smith, Caroline county, Maryland, from seed of Quaker.
  • Smith | fruit_size | A. Norby reported fruit size as one and seven-eighths of an inch in 1902.
  • Smith | productivity | In 1903 A. Norby described it as only fairly productive.
  • Smith | productivity | In 1904 A. Norby described it as a good bearer and averaging large.
  • Smith | recommendation_context | In 1903 A. Norby said it was of no special value.
  • Smith | recommendation_context | In 1904 A. Norby judged it not equal to De Soto.
  • Smith | recommendation_context | Not in the Station orchard.
  • Smith | taxon_context | Smith is listed as an Americana plum.
  • Speer | description_snippet | H. C. Warner of Forestburg, South Dakota, reported in 1903 that this variety was too small.
  • Speer | entry_hardiness_observation | In the old Station orchard the trees have proven hardy.
  • Speer | entry_location | The source location given is Cedar Falls, Iowa.
  • Speer | fruit_size | The fruit runs too small; at its best the size is medium or below.
  • Speer | productivity | In the old Station orchard the trees overbear.
  • Speer | selection_origin_reference | A wild variety from J. A. Speer, Cedar Falls, Iowa.
  • Speer | taxon_context | Speer is listed as an Americana plum.
Figures Removed
  • none
Citations Removed
  • none

Available Page Versions

IDVariantStatusModelSpecializationCountsSourceCompare
780archivist-1.0activegpt-5.4visual_page_generalist2 cultivars / 20 claims / 0 figuresOpen source page
3295archivist-1.0candidategpt-5.4visual_page_generalist2 cultivars / 13 claims / 0 figuresOpen source pageCompare to active