Archivist Page Review

Review parser variants for one source page, compare outputs, and jump directly to the source evidence.

Document: 17 Plums in South Dakota

Source page: Open page 86 in document reader

Institution: Open PRAIRIE | Publisher: | Year: | Pages: 89

Source URL: https://openprairie.sdstate.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1092&context=agexperimentsta_bulletins

Selected Versions

Left: archivist-1.0 (fragment 3658)

Right: archivist-1.0 (fragment 10888)

Next Step

Reprocess/promote controls are the next UI layer. The data foundation is now versioned and diffable.

Page Version Diff

Cultivars Added

none

Claims Added

Aitkin | hardiness_code_expansion | Implicitly among the hardiest group in the correspondent's view of northern plums, with repeated successful ripening.
Aitkin | productivity | Reported as reliably fruiting to ripeness in cold-region correspondence.
Bixby | entry_location | Listed within a multi-variety trial set from Manitoba correspondence.
Bixby | recommendation_context | No specific performance metric appears for this cultivar on the page.
Cheney | entry_hardiness_observation | Described as one of the two hardiest and one of the few to fruit to ripeness in the reported northern trials.
Cheney | productivity | Documented as fruiting to ripeness.
Cottrell | entry_location | Named as part of the Manitoba trial collection.
Cottrell | selection_origin_reference | Implied to share the same Minnesota-nursery trial channel as nearby listed cultivars.
De Soto | entry_hardiness_observation | Observed by correspondents as often hard to ripen and frequently affected by freezing before maturity in northern locations.
De Soto | entry_location | Referenced by growers in south-central North Dakota and Manitoba.
De Soto | recommendation_context | Its performance in far-north trials is presented cautiously and is not presented as broadly recommended for coldest sites.
Forest Garden | entry_hardiness_observation | Showed severe annual top growth freeze-back in Manitoba report.
Forest Garden | productivity | Not yet reported as fruiting by one contributor at time of writing.
Hawkeye | entry_hardiness_observation | Reported as not ripening in south-central North Dakota during two seasons.
Hawkeye | recommendation_context | This non-ripening behavior is treated as negative for very northern use.
Mankato | entry_location | Part of the set of cultivars currently under observation in Manitoba-origin correspondence.
Mankato | recommendation_context | No positive performance statement recorded on this page extract.
New Ulm | entry_hardiness_observation | Referenced as one of the hardy native-type plums in the far-north discussion.
New Ulm | recommendation_context | Grouped with the hardier native candidates rather than southern-introduced types.
Ocheeda | entry_location | Listed as a trial variety from the Manitoba correspondence.

Figures Added

none

Citations Added

Hansen, N.E. "Plums in South Dakota" (1905). South Dakota Agricultural College. South Dakota State Agricultural Experiment Station Bulletins, Paper 93.

Cultivars Removed

none

Claims Removed

Aitkin | entry_hardiness_observation | It was described as perhaps one of the two hardiest of the northern named plums tried there.
Aitkin | entry_location | Alex Alin had planted this cultivar in Fullerton, Dickey County, North Dakota.
Aitkin | entry_location | D. W. Buchanan of St. Charles, Manitoba, reported on this cultivar in March 1905.
Aitkin | productivity | It had not fruited yet in Alin's planting at the time of his January 1904 report.
Aitkin | productivity | It was one of the only plums Buchanan had fruited to ripeness.
Bixby | entry_hardiness_observation | It was among a broader group for which Buchanan said a number freeze back badly, though a few appear quite hardy.
Bixby | entry_location | D. W. Buchanan listed this cultivar among those in his Manitoba planting.
Cheney | entry_hardiness_observation | A number of the varieties under test freeze back badly, but a few appear quite hardy; Cheney is singled out as one that fruited.
Cheney | entry_hardiness_observation | It was described as perhaps one of the two hardiest of the northern named plums tried there.
Cheney | entry_location | D. W. Buchanan of St. Charles, Manitoba, reported on this cultivar in March 1905.
Cheney | productivity | Cheney and Aitkin have ripened fruit.
Cheney | productivity | It was one of the only plums Buchanan had fruited to ripeness.
Cottrell | entry_hardiness_observation | It was among a broader group for which Buchanan said a number freeze back badly, though a few appear quite hardy.
Cottrell | entry_location | D. W. Buchanan listed this cultivar among those in his Manitoba planting.
De Soto | entry_hardiness_observation | It did not ripen there during the last two seasons mentioned in the January 16, 1904 correspondence.
De Soto | entry_hardiness_observation | Some trees proved fairly hardy in Manitoba, but the fruit was usually frozen back before it was ripe.
De Soto | entry_location | Alex Alin of Fullerton, Dickey County, North Dakota, reported on this cultivar.
De Soto | entry_location | D. W. Buchanan of St. Charles, Manitoba, also reported on this cultivar.
De Soto | recommendation_context | The writer considered it safest not to recommend such late-ripening varieties as far north as his location.
Forest Garden | entry_hardiness_observation | Forest Garden and Wyant had frozen back nearly all the new growth every year in Buchanan's experience.

Figures Removed

none

Citations Removed

A. Norby, of Madison, S. D., reported in 1904 to the South Dakota State Horticultural Society as follows
Alex Alin, Fullerton, Dickey county, North Dakota (south central), writes under date of January 16th, 1904
D. W. Buchanan, St. Charles, Manitoba, writes in March, 1905

Available Page Versions

ID	Variant	Status	Model	Specialization	Counts	Source	Compare
828	archivist-1.0	active	gpt-5.4	visual_page_generalist	17 cultivars / 53 claims / 0 figures	Open source page
3342	archivist-1.0	candidate	gpt-5.4	visual_page_generalist	17 cultivars / 35 claims / 0 figures	Open source page	Compare to active