Archivist Page Review

Review parser variants for one source page, compare outputs, and jump directly to the source evidence.

Document: 23 Fruit Culture

Source page: Open page 32 in document reader

Institution: Open PRAIRIE | Publisher: | Year: | Pages: 41

Source URL: https://openprairie.sdstate.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1049&context=agexperimentsta_bulletins

Selected Versions

Left: archivist-1.0 (fragment 3881)

Right: archivist-1.0 (fragment 11455)

Next Step

Reprocess/promote controls are the next UI layer. The data foundation is now versioned and diffable.

Page Version Diff

Cultivars Added

De Sota
Haas
Perry Russet
Uter'S Red
Walbridge
Westfield Seek-No-Further
Yellow Transparent

Claims Added

Antonovka | anecdote_snippet | Noted as one of the few Russian apples with useful fruited performance.
Antonovka | entry_hardiness_observation | Observed to be a good tree under the reported orchard conditions.
Antonovka | fruit_size | Described as producing large, handsome fruit.
Antonovka | fruiting | Fruit maturity is early fall, slightly later than Duchess in this location.
Concord | productivity | Identified as one of the highest-yielding varieties in a small vineyard of approximately twenty entries.
De Sota | anecdote_snippet | Reported as among the better-performing native plum types relative to unnamed alternatives.
Delaware | productivity | Consistently among the best-fruiting varieties in the observed vineyard block.
Duchess | productivity | Duchess was repeatedly included among useful/fruiting entries in the report and later named in a high-performing list.
Duchess | recommendation_context | Named as one of the most profitable orchard entries in the report context.
Duchess | selection_origin_reference | The orchard planting included Duchess as a principal cultivar from the reported 1886 establishment and subsequent replanting phase.
Haas | recommendation_context | Listed as one of the most profitable apples in the correspondent's comparative list.
Houghton | productivity | Part of a gooseberry cultivar group with sustained ten-year profitability.
Janesville | productivity | Included among the top fruiting grape cultivars in the observed vineyard sample.
Perry Russet | recommendation_context | Listed among productive cultivars in correspondent's top list.
Prince Albert | productivity | Listed as steadily profitable in a decade-long currant performance note.
Red Dutch | productivity | Characterized as steadily profitable over ten years.
Titovka | recommendation_context | Listed with core productive apples in the reported planting list.
Titovka | selection_origin_reference | Used in subsequent plantings after initial orchard establishment and later replanting.
Titus | recommendation_context | Mentioned for confirmation/identification rather than detailed performance description.
Titus | source_reference_abbreviation | Named explicitly in the identification request response as one of the few Russian cultivars identified with certainty.

Figures Added

none

Citations Added

Correspondence from Ramsey (Nov. 12, 1895) and Oliver Gibbs, Jr. (Oct. 4, 1896) reported in narrative.
Hansen, N.E. "Fruit Culture" (1897). Bulletins. Paper 50.

Cultivars Removed

Desoto
Large Anis

Claims Removed

Antonovka | anecdote_snippet | The grower suggests it might be later on heavy soil with the right elevation and exposure.
Antonovka | fruit_color | The fruit is described as handsome in appearance.
Antonovka | fruit_size | The fruit is large.
Antonovka | growth_habit | Antonovka is described as a good tree.
Antonovka | productivity | Antonovka was among the apples of which the grower had all he could use at home in an earlier fruiting year.
Antonovka | storage_duration | In this orchard it was only an early fall apple, a trifle later than Duchess.
Concord | productivity | Concord was one of the vineyard varieties that gave the most fruit.
Delaware | productivity | Delaware was one of the vineyard varieties that gave the most fruit.
Desoto | productivity | Among many good native plums, nothing was better than DeSoto for profit.
Desoto | recommendation_context | DeSoto is singled out as the best profitable native plum in this report.
Duchess | description_snippet | Duchess is used as a benchmark for season, with Antonovka described as a trifle later than Duchess.
Duchess | productivity | By the next bearing year, the grower had all he could use at home of Duchess apples.
Houghton | productivity | Houghton gooseberries had been steadily profitable through all these ten years.
Janesville | productivity | Janesville was one of the vineyard varieties that gave the most fruit.
Large Anis | productivity | Large Anis was among the apples of which the grower had all he could use at home in an earlier fruiting year.
Large Anis | taxon_context | Large Anis is mentioned among Russian apple varieties in the orchard.
Prince Albert | productivity | Prince Albert currants had been steadily profitable through all these ten years.
Red Dutch | productivity | Red Dutch currants had been steadily profitable through all these ten years.
Titovka | description_snippet | Of the Russian apples that had fruited, the grower thought most of the fruit was Titovka, identified here with Titus.
Titovka | productivity | Titovka was among the apples of which the grower had all he could use at home in an earlier fruiting year.

Figures Removed

none

Citations Removed

Ramsey, S. D., Nov. 12, 1895. Oliver Gibbs, Jr.
Under date of Oct. 4, 1896, Mr. Gibbs reports a good crop of fruit and expresses his desire to have the lost varieties identified as soon as practicable.
trees from the Iowa Agricultural College, leaving the selection of varieties entirely to Prof. Budd

Available Page Versions

ID	Variant	Status	Model	Specialization	Counts	Source	Compare
1039	archivist-1.0	active	gpt-5.4	visual_page_generalist	16 cultivars / 27 claims / 0 figures	Open source page
3720	archivist-1.0	candidate	gpt-5.4	visual_page_generalist	21 cultivars / 31 claims / 0 figures	Open source page	Compare to active