Archivist Page Review

Review parser variants for one source page, compare outputs, and jump directly to the source evidence.

Document: 23 Fruit Culture

Source page: Open page 6 in document reader

Institution: Open PRAIRIE | Publisher: | Year: | Pages: 41

Source URL: https://openprairie.sdstate.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1049&context=agexperimentsta_bulletins

Selected Versions

Left: archivist-1.0 (fragment 3855)

Right: archivist-1.0 (fragment 11423)

Next Step

Reprocess/promote controls are the next UI layer. The data foundation is now versioned and diffable.

Page Version Diff

Cultivars Added

none

Claims Added

Charlamoff | entry_hardiness_observation | Reported to have proven considerably hardier than Duchess at Wm. Peterson's orchard and hardy at Brookings.
Charlamoff | entry_pedigree | The text states there are two distinct kinds under the Charlamoff name; this entry refers to the one doing well in observed Minnesota testing.
Charlamoff | flavor_profile | Quality is said to be much better for eating out of hand than comparable options.
Charlamoff | fruit_color | Coloring is similar to Duchess.
Charlamoff | fruit_size | Fruit is described as roundish conical in shape.
Charlamoff | growth_habit | Tree described as spreading habit.
Charlamoff | recommendation_context | Rapidly gaining favor with Minnesota fruit growers.
Charlamoff | selection_origin_reference | Identified as Russian importation No. 262.
Christmas | recommendation_context | Listed as a tardy bearer.
Duchess | entry_hardiness_observation | Duchess is not as reliable in the severer sections of Minnesota as Hibernal or Charlamoff.
Duchess | flavor_profile | Not explicitly framed as eating quality first, but noted as commercially useful and suitable for table use when fully ripened.
Duchess | fruit_color | Fruit is described as beautifully colored.
Duchess | fruit_size | Fruit is described as large.
Duchess | productivity | The variety is characterized as very productive and has borne heavily in the Brookings station orchard.
Duchess | recommendation_context | Described as one of the best of the older list in southern South Dakota; considered generally popular in the Northwest.
Duchess | source_reference_abbreviation | The American Pomological Society is referenced as using the official cultivar name Oldenburg, while western societies retain 'Duchess' for continuity.
Duchess | storage_duration | The text notes cold storage interest and better pricing later in season for fruit stored from August/September harvest windows.
Hibernal | description_snippet | The text presents Hibernal as a reference point in a Russian-group hardiness discussion rather than only as a standalone prose paragraph.
Hibernal | entry_hardiness_observation | Further context (neighboring page text) characterizes Hibernal as hardier than Oldenburg and very spreading habit.
Hibernal | recommendation_context | Its performance is used as a standard in comparisons for colder Minnesota conditions.

Figures Added

none

Citations Added

Green, S. B. (University of Minnesota) note on Recumbent (Lieby).
Hansen, N.E., "Fruit Culture" (1897). Bulletins. Paper 50.
Minnesota Fruit List notes (referenced by the text as containing recognized value for Recumbent/Lieby group).

Cultivars Removed

Lieby

Claims Removed

Charlamoff | description_snippet | Its season is a little later than Duchess.
Charlamoff | description_snippet | The fruit is roundish conical and strongly ridged and ribbed around the cavity or stem end.
Charlamoff | description_snippet | There appear to be two distinct kinds under the name Charlamoff.
Charlamoff | entry_hardiness_observation | At Waconia it has proven considerably hardier than Duchess.
Charlamoff | entry_hardiness_observation | The tree is hardy at Brookings.
Charlamoff | flavor_profile | Its quality is much better for eating out of hand.
Charlamoff | fruit_color | The fruit colors like Duchess.
Charlamoff | fruit_size | The fruit is medium sized.
Charlamoff | growth_habit | It is of spreading habit.
Charlamoff | recommendation_context | It is rapidly gaining favor with Minnesota fruit growers.
Charlamoff | selection_origin_reference | The entry refers to the form that has done well in Wm. Peterson's orchard at Waconia, 30 miles northwest of Minneapolis.
Charlamoff | selection_origin_reference | This is No. 262 of the Russian importation.
Christmas | productivity | Identified as a tardy bearer.
Duchess | description_snippet | The name now recognized by the American Pomological Society is Oldenburg, but the name Duchess is retained by western societies to prevent confusion.
Duchess | description_snippet | This is also called Duchess of Oldenburg.
Duchess | entry_hardiness_observation | In the severer sections of Minnesota, Duchess has not stood as well as Hibernal or Charlamoff.
Duchess | entry_hardiness_observation | Its hardiness and productiveness made it very popular throughout the Northwest.
Duchess | fruit_color | The fruit has beautiful coloring.
Duchess | fruit_size | The fruit is large.
Duchess | productivity | It has borne heavily and the trees are standing well in the Station orchard at Brookings, planted in 1888.

Figures Removed

none

Citations Removed

Prof. S. B. Green, of the University of Minnesota, writes as follows
the notes to the Minnesota fruit list

Available Page Versions

ID	Variant	Status	Model	Specialization	Counts	Source	Compare
1013	archivist-1.0	active	gpt-5.4	visual_page_generalist	13 cultivars / 44 claims / 0 figures	Open source page
3698	archivist-1.0	candidate	gpt-5.4	visual_page_generalist	12 cultivars / 36 claims / 0 figures	Open source page	Compare to active