Archivist Page Review

Review parser variants for one source page, compare outputs, and jump directly to the source evidence.

Document: 7 Minnesota #1695

Source page: Open page 86 in document reader

Institution: University of Minnesota | Publisher: University of Minnesota | Year: | Pages: 138

Source URL: https://conservancy.umn.edu/server/api/core/bitstreams/891e96c2-d751-4fea-9f35-51fec97c7043/content

Selected Versions

Left: archivist-1.6.68-spark (fragment 928)

Right: archivist-1.0 (fragment 10941)

Next Step

Reprocess/promote controls are the next UI layer. The data foundation is now versioned and diffable.

Page Version Diff

Cultivars Added

Plum 'Alderman'
Plum 'Compass'
Plum 'Gracious'
Plum 'Hazel'
Plum 'Hennepin'
Plum 'Monitor'
Plum 'Mount Royal'
Plum 'Pipestone'
Plum 'South Dakota'
Plum 'Todd'
Plum 'Whittaker'
Plum 'Winona'

Claims Added

Plum 'Alderman' | storage_duration | Field-environment germination for Plum 'Alderman' was 16.7% after 25 months and 16.7% after 1 month.
Plum 'Compass' | storage_duration | Field-environment germination for Plum 'Compass' was 20.8% after 25 months and 29.2% after 1 month.
Plum 'Gracious' | storage_duration | Field-environment germination for Plum 'Gracious' was 25.0% after 25 months and 54.2% after 1 month.
Plum 'Hazel' | storage_duration | Field-environment germination for Plum 'Hazel' was 50.0% after 25 months of storage and 70.8% after 1 month.
Plum 'Hennepin' | description_snippet | Asterisked values for Plum 'Hennepin' suggest significant difference across months for this cultivar within-table context.
Plum 'Hennepin' | storage_duration | Field-environment germination for Plum 'Hennepin' was 95.8% after 25 months and 75.0% after 1 month.
Plum 'Monitor' | storage_duration | Field-environment germination for Plum 'Monitor' was 4.2% after 25 months and 0.0% after 1 month.
Plum 'Mount Royal' | storage_duration | Field-environment germination for Plum 'Mount Royal' was 4.2% after 25 months and 16.7% after 1 month.
Plum 'Pipestone' | storage_duration | Field-environment germination for Plum 'Pipestone' was 4.2% after 25 months and 12.5% after 1 month.
Plum 'South Dakota' | storage_duration | Field-environment germination for Plum 'South Dakota' was 70.8% after both 25 and 1 months of storage.
Plum 'Todd' | storage_duration | Field-environment germination for Plum 'Todd' was 50.0% after 25 months and 58.3% after 1 month.
Plum 'Whittaker' | storage_duration | Field-environment germination for Plum 'Whittaker' was 62.4% after 25 months and 75.0% after 1 month.
Plum 'Winona' | storage_duration | Field-environment germination for Plum 'Winona' was 20.8% after 25 months and 16.7% after 1 month.

Figures Added

none

Citations Added

Kostick, Sarah Anne (2016). A Survey of Winter-Hardy Prunus Species: Evaluation of Seed Germination, Seedling Establishment, and Pollen Viability. Master's thesis, University of Minnesota.

Cultivars Removed

'Alderman'
'Compass'
'Gracious'
'Hazel'
'Hennepin'
'Monitor'
'Mount Royal'
'Pipestone'
'South Dakota'
'Todd'
'Whittaker'
'Winona'

Claims Removed

'Alderman' | description_snippet | Row belongs to the plum cultivar subsection of Table 5.
'Alderman' | storage_duration | Plum 'Alderman' had 16.7% germination at both 25 months and 1 month.
'Compass' | description_snippet | Listed in the plum subsection of Table 5 continued.
'Compass' | storage_duration | Plum 'Compass' showed 20.8% germination at 25 months and 29.2% at 1 month (Table 5).
'Gracious' | description_snippet | Listed as a named plum cultivar in Table 5 (continued).
'Gracious' | storage_duration | Plum 'Gracious' showed 25.0% germination at 25 months and 54.2% at 1 month in field storage data.
'Hazel' | description_snippet | Appears as a named cultivar row in Table 5 (continued).
'Hazel' | storage_duration | Field-environment germination for Plum 'Hazel' was 50.0% at 25 months and 70.8% at 1 month storage (Table 5).
'Hennepin' | description_snippet | Appears as a high-performing plum cultivar row in Table 5 continuation.
'Hennepin' | storage_duration | Plum 'Hennepin' had high field germination, 95.8% after 25 months and 75.0% after 1 month (Table 5), with asterisked significance markers.
'Monitor' | description_snippet | Included in the plum continuation of Table 5.
'Monitor' | storage_duration | Plum 'Monitor' field germination was 4.2% at 25 months and 0.0% at 1 month (Table 5).
'Mount Royal' | description_snippet | Included as a plum cultivar entry in Table 5 (continued).
'Mount Royal' | storage_duration | Plum 'Mount Royal' field germination was 4.2% at 25 months and 16.7% at 1 month (Table 5).
'Pipestone' | description_snippet | Table row listed under the plum section of Table 5.
'Pipestone' | storage_duration | Plum 'Pipestone' had 4.2% germination at 25 months and 12.5% at 1 month in Table 5.
'South Dakota' | description_snippet | Named in the plum cultivar section of Table 5 continued page.
'South Dakota' | storage_duration | Plum 'South Dakota' showed 70.8% germination at both 25 months and 1 month in field environment trials (Table 5).
'Todd' | description_snippet | Listed as a row entry in the plum section of Table 5.
'Todd' | storage_duration | Plum 'Todd' showed 50.0% germination at 25 months and 58.3% at 1 month in field conditions (Table 5).

Figures Removed

none

Citations Removed

Table 5 is part of Sarah Anne Kostick's 2016 thesis "A Survey of Winter-Hardy Prunus Species: Evaluation of Seed Germination, Seedling Establishment, and Pollen Viability."

Available Page Versions

ID	Variant	Status	Model	Specialization	Counts	Source	Compare
334	archivist-1.6.68-spark	active	gpt-5.4	visual_page_generalist	12 cultivars / 24 claims / 0 figures	Open source page
3377	archivist-1.0	candidate	gpt-5.4	visual_page_generalist	12 cultivars / 13 claims / 0 figures	Open source page	Compare to active